Karn Colorless

The commander rule restricting what colors can actually be in your deck is annoying. It's unnecessary. The ruling that should matter is "A deck may not generate mana outside its colours. If an effect would generate mana of an illegal colour, it generates colourless mana instead.", then that is it. Hybrid mana could be used in decks that have a different color identity, I don't know why commander has it so that decks that could normally play these cards - cannot do it in this format.

Nothing would really change, besides colorless commanders can include basic lands, and it wouldn't matter. Decks can use hybrid mana, and cards with different colored modes Obelisk of Alara or cards with off color flash back costs - they can't produce the mana, so who cares if you wanna waste a spot on something you can't maximize the effect of?

Anti cards are banned in vintage. Therefore they are banned in edh. The edh format is specifically vintag legal cards minus the cards in th banned list

Aren't the legendary eldrazi's and Karn, liberated banned from EDH as well? And btw don't forget sensei's divining top! And equipment cards like all 5 of the swords, hexproof/shroud equips, and darksteel plate! And All is dust would be fantastic in here

Only emrakul is banned. And karn liberated is not either. Agreed on all is dust!

Honestly the best thing about a colorless general is that you don't have to run basics. There are so many colorless utility lands out there! I'll name a few (sorry if you already have some just listing ones I know)

temple of the false god
strip mine
tectonic edge
encroaching wastes
mishra's factory
rogue's passage
crystal vein
dread statuary
hall of the bandit lord
cavern of souls
mutavault
And as someone said before the urza tron lands are great

Quote from: Wsuryanjeska on May 08, 2013, 06:27:42 PM

Aren't the legendary eldrazi's and Karn, liberated banned from EDH as well? And btw don't forget sensei's divining top! And equipment cards like all 5 of the swords, hexproof/shroud equips, and darksteel plate! And All is dust would be fantastic in here

Only emrakul is banned. And karn liberated is not either. Agreed on all is dust!

mlearnerd!!