Mafia Day 2 Time to lynch!

[Gorzo]

I think that there should be some rule against editing since it destroys the purpose of the game.

Player A says "I'm Mafia!"
Player B notices this and votes him.
Player A editing his post saying "I'm Town!"
Player A leads a crusade against Player B for lying.

Fair enough. My edit was just to remove a couple names from the list of people who I thought hadn't posted yet after I realized they had, and that I am super observant. I'll add new posts to fix such mistakes here on out instead of edits, even though the OCD in will go crazy

How much time is left to vote before the official tally?

[Sagemaster]

I would like to retract my vote and vote for coffee because he seems to be manipulating everyone away from Darkarts and beleren and that makes me suspicious of the three

How do you know that those three are mafia?

Vote Sagemaster

I don't know that they are but looking at coffee's speech he kinda pulled everyone away from Darkarts and Jace and those two were fighting each other for a while so I'm suspicious of them all haha

[Sagemaster]

To proph: Yes, all 3 voted for me at the same time. They could be passing notes to each other. Also they seem to be unrelated to all the others. In my studies (what studies I have), the mafia likes to make their actions appear random and unrelated, though there is definite organization behind it. Anyone can observe this if he or she be willing to think critically.

If those three are the mafia, we must take them out one by one. The mafia has strength in numbers. Ever seen a head mafia make an assasination by himself?

Before I cast my vote I would like to hear more from those three lynch-happy hippos, so to speak.

But you're the one giving all these long rants...you're confusing me which is why I voted for you... Also...CbStrad didn't say anything and you voted him right away contradicting yourself...

I vote CbStrad.

He was the first to hop on the lyncherator bandwagon of coffee, so he must be the ringleader if indeed my theory is correct.

[Sagemaster]

And wait are we allowed to pm others telling them what we are and to talk about the game to lynch off people? I don't remember milo saying we could do that unless it was being a cop and pming him...

[Gorzo]

And wait are we allowed to pm others telling them what we are and to talk about the game to lynch off people? I don't remember milo saying we could do that unless it was being a cop and pming him...

PMing people and telling your role kind ruins the spirit of the game, does it not?

Besides, PMs can lie too. If someone PMs me that they are any role, I'm thinking "well this guy is mafia for sure"

[darkarts981]

And wait are we allowed to pm others telling them what we are and to talk about the game to lynch off people? I don't remember milo saying we could do that unless it was being a cop and pming him...

The mafia communicates at night

[Coffee Vampire]

I just did rants to get into the game! I want to build a character for myself; it makes the game more interesting.

And actually, CbStrad did say something. He has posted 3 times. Two of his posts vote for people to be lynched. The reasons? For his first suspect the reason he stated was:

In an attempt to get some discussion going, I want everyone to answer these questions:

1. Why are these two people being considered to lynch? They haven't really said anything scummy.
2. Why are you voting for one of these two people?

Because random XD

Because random? Okay. And the reason he voted for me?

I would like to retract my vote and vote for coffee because he seems to be manipulating everyone away from Darkarts and beleren and that makes me suspicious of the three

Agreed. That much drama is a tad suspect. Retracting my vote and voting for Coffee

...because I try to bring drama into the game. Notice he is agreeing with sagemaster, who retracted his vote and voted for me at the same time as Cbstrad.

So actually, CbStrad did say things, and I did not contradict myself. Nothing personal, but I would appreciate it if you did a little research before saying things like that.

[darkarts981]

I just did rants to get into the game! I want to build a character for myself; it makes the game more interesting.

And actually, CbStrad did say something. He has posted 3 times. Two of his posts vote for people to be lynched. The reasons? For his first suspect the reason he stated was:

In an attempt to get some discussion going, I want everyone to answer these questions:

1. Why are these two people being considered to lynch? They haven't really said anything scummy.
2. Why are you voting for one of these two people?

Because random XD

Because random? Okay. And the reason he voted for me?

I would like to retract my vote and vote for coffee because he seems to be manipulating everyone away from Darkarts and beleren and that makes me suspicious of the three

Agreed. That much drama is a tad suspect. Retracting my vote and voting for Coffee

...because I try to bring drama into the game. Notice he is agreeing with sagemaster, who retracted his vote and voted for me at the same time as Cbstrad.

So actually, CbStrad did say things, and I did not contradict myself. Nothing personal, but I would appreciate it if you did a little research before saying things like that.

Excellent points, I sy also mention that sagemaster seemed to be defending CbStrad, if the mafia knows who each other are, then sagemaster is a suspect as well!

[Coffee Vampire]

Well the choosing process was random so you could be paired with sagemaster just the same.

And if you want to go with sayings to prove points:

"He who waves the finger has three waving back at himself."

[darkarts981]

"He who waves the finger has three waving back at himself."

😚there needs to be a "just sayin" accompanied with an innocent laugh in there somewhere!

[Coffee Vampire]

This has to be irony at its...well, irony.

[Milo109]

To clarify several points.
1) All roles were made using random.com
2) I cannot stop you from pming outside of the forums, but you cannot state your role. Please follow the spirit of the game, not the letter

[ntheawsome]

This drama makes me lol. People will vote for me because I said that, but I really laughed out loud.

[Coffee Vampire]

I have a suggestion: next day, (day 2) we should not be able to change votes. This will discourage hasty choices and encourage more truth-seeking conversations... = more fun and involvement!

Also, I encourage everyone to vote and be involved. Those who have not spoken up yet, let's go!

[loop-s-pool]

The ones most involved in the discussion will most likely be the Mafia because it is more interesting to be part of it and lead people astray. Some Mafia veterans will always post but the newbies somewhat detatched will not be as excited and tied to the thread as possible. That being said I don't think Coffee has played before so my theory is he has ties to the Mafia. This is not my final vote, but I'd like to see what the other members of the town have to say.