Liquimetal Coating and Splinter

[LinzInTheBarn]

Okay...crap situation here.

Opponent uses {Liquimetal Coating} ability and targets one of my plains. Then he plays {Splinter} and says all of my lands are now removed from the game.

I disagree. Help please!! Thanks

[imFourth of Phils]

Okay...crap situation here.

Opponent uses {Liquimetal Coating} ability and targets one of my plains. Then he plays {Splinter} and says all of my lands are now removed from the game.

I disagree. Help please!! Thanks

honestly.. its a combo your plains will become artifact.. and splinter say's artifact and the SAME NAME, yes.. your opponent is rude

[LinzInTheBarn]

Seriously? That's just so limp.

[LinzInTheBarn]

Plus, it only changes that one plains to an artifact. I have no other 'artifact plains'...so...doesn't seem right.

[Sardok]

One of your plains is an artifact via {Liquidmetal Coating}.

{Splinter} targets that plains.

As part of the resolution, your artifact plains is exiled.

{Splinter} searches for all cards with the same name (Plains) and exiles them.

Seems straightforward.

[LinzInTheBarn]

Yes, super straightforward. That's why I asked. Obviously.

[LinzInTheBarn]

Ah, wait! His {Splinter} doesn't say 'same name' like this one's text! It says 'copies of that card'

[LinzInTheBarn]

His is from Urza.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

His is from Urza.

It doesn't change the function of the card. The errata is the same as all newer copies. Exact errata can be found online and on this app in the text box above the card picture. This is a dick move, howvere you do get to keep your Plains that you have on the field, just to clarify.

[Sardok]

His is from Urza.

It doesn't change the function of the card. The errata is the same as all newer copies. Exact errata can be found online and on this app in the text box above the card picture. This is a dick move, howvere you do get to keep your Plains that you have on the field, just to clarify.

This is incorrect, {Splinter} exiles the targeted artifact, in this case the plains.

[Sardok]

Yes, super straightforward. That's why I asked. Obviously.

Your sarcasm is noted.

[Nfidel2k]

His is from Urza.

It doesn't change the function of the card. The errata is the same as all newer copies. Exact errata can be found online and on this app in the text box above the card picture. This is a dick move, howvere you do get to keep your Plains that you have on the field, just to clarify.

This is incorrect, {Splinter} exiles the targeted artifact, in this case the plains.

He would keep any plains on the field other than the one targeted by splinter...

[Sardok]

His is from Urza.

It doesn't change the function of the card. The errata is the same as all newer copies. Exact errata can be found online and on this app in the text box above the card picture. This is a dick move, howvere you do get to keep your Plains that you have on the field, just to clarify.

This is incorrect, {Splinter} exiles the targeted artifact, in this case the plains.

He would keep any plains on the field other than the one targeted by splinter...

Yep, the original wording implied that you would keep the plains that was targeted.

[particle]

His is from Urza.

It doesn't change the function of the card. The errata is the same as all newer copies. Exact errata can be found online and on this app in the text box above the card picture. This is a dick move, howvere you do get to keep your Plains that you have on the field, just to clarify.

This is incorrect, {Splinter} exiles the targeted artifact, in this case the plains.

He would keep any plains on the field other than the one targeted by splinter...

Yep, the original wording implied that you would keep the plains that was targeted.

I don't see that. The first thing it says is remove target artifact from the game...

[LinzInTheBarn]

Thank you all for the help. My boyfriend is a dick, so this combo is fitting!