Esper Control

Started by Mattao19, October 15, 2014, 08:18:54 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mattao19

This list took down a state championship I'm building it for a tourney on sat any thoughts?

26 LANDS
4 {Temple of Deceit}
4 {Temple of Silence}
4 {Temple of Enlightenment}
3 {Island}
2 {Plains}
2 {Caves of Koilos}
2 {Polluted Delta}
2 {Flooded Strand}
2 {Swamp}
1 {Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth}

4 CREATURES
3 {Nyx-Fleece Ram}
1 {Resolute Archangel}

23 INSTANTS and SORC.
4 {Dissolve}
4 {Hero's Downfall}
4 {Thoughtseize}
3 {End Hostilities}
3 {Divination}
3 {Dig Through Time}
1 {Drown in Sorrow}
1 {Utter End}

7 OTHER SPELLS
3 {Elspeth, Sun's Champion}
3 {Ashiok, Nightmare Weaver}
1 {Jace, the Living Guildpact}

SIDEBOARD
1 {Resolute Archangel}
2 {Drown in Sorrow}
2 {Brimaz, King of Oreskos}
2 {Disdainful Stroke}
1 {Gainsay}
1 {Negate}
2 {Bile Blight}
2 {Banishing Light}
1 {Last Breath}
1 {Deicide}

My thoughts are -1 Jace, -1 Ashiok to +1 Utter End and +1 {Bile Blight}

Also 4 dissolves seems tough in thinking of -4 Dissolves +2 {Disdainful stroke} +1 Bile Blight} (to make 2 MB BBs) and +1 {Divination}

lotrwk

I feel like -2 ram +1 dig and +1 Sphinx are needed. Ram isn't too great, and dig is so good, as is Sphinx.

Mattao19

Quote from: lotrwk on October 15, 2014, 08:23:39 PM
I feel like -2 ram +1 dig and +1 Sphinx are needed. Ram isn't too great, and dig is so good, as is Sphinx.

The thing is is that vs Jeskai Tempo/any burn deck you need to gain some life or else you flat out lose. I've thought about sphinx but I feel like it might be unnecessary. I think I need to add the 4th dig like it's just so good

lotrwk

Except against jeskai wins, they'll just wait and overwhelm you. You don't have quite as much removal as the mardu control deck, but you have the three end hostilities. If you don't draw those, multiple attack a from a big/2 rabble and a mantis rider will kill you. Also, ram can't kill the tokens that rabble makes. That's actually very relevant

MuggyWuggy

Ram is so good tho
2 or 3 on board and doesn't matter much jeskai burns

Mattao19

Quote from: lotrwk on October 15, 2014, 08:50:14 PM
Except against jeskai wins, they'll just wait and overwhelm you. You don't have quite as much removal as the mardu control deck, but you have the three end hostilities. If you don't draw those, multiple attack a from a big/2 rabble and a mantis rider will kill you. Also, ram can't kill the tokens that rabble makes. That's actually very relevant

Valid points but seeing as I run 4 downfalls 3 end 3 (soon to be 4 Digs)  I feel like it won't be an issue especially once I add in a bile blight

lotrwk

Seems fine I guess. Not the biggest issue in the world I guess

Mattao19

Quote from: lotrwk on October 15, 2014, 09:51:14 PM
Seems fine I guess. Not the biggest issue in the world I guess

True well I'll be play testing a lot too :D

lotrwk

Yeah, I really think Esper is the way to go. U/b
With Elspeth and wraths better than vault lol

Mattao19

Quote from: lotrwk on October 15, 2014, 10:02:35 PM
Yeah, I really think Esper is the way to go. U/b
With Elspeth and wraths better than vault lol

No kidding lol :P I'm just expecting a lot of Abzan and Green Devotion so I figure that Control will be well suited :P

lotrwk

Not with mono black aggro running around! Muahahahahaha

Mattao19

Quote from: lotrwk on October 15, 2014, 10:05:09 PM
Not with mono black aggro running around! Muahahahahaha

Lol true but I haven't seen any MonoBlack aggro around I'm mostly scared of Jeskai Tempo and Ascendancy Combo

Ekann1

Quote from: Mattao19 on October 15, 2014, 10:07:10 PM
Ascendancy Combo
Thoughtseize is your best friend against this deck.

Mattao19

Quote from: E.kann1 on October 15, 2014, 10:57:00 PM
Quote from: Mattao19 on October 15, 2014, 10:07:10 PM
Ascendancy Combo
Thoughtseize is your best friend against this deck.

I know but still with Commune and Dig in their deck TSeize might not stop it all together.

BaBa BLaCkSHeeT

I posted my Azorious control deck earlier I believe you commented on it. It was doing well play testing online and with friends topped at a standard tournament Tuesday tonight however the deck flopped. I posted the list I used to top on Tuesday but I was drawing very timely that day as opposed to today couldn't find lands often just unlucky!

Long story short im swapping to esper with the rise of jeskai and abzdan from the pro tour there's just slim to no question esper is better and namely here's why:

{bile blight}
{ashiok, nightmare weaver}
{utter end}

I haven't tested jaces bounce yet how has he been performing in matches for you?

I'd strongly suggest cutting the Rams main board even against jeskai they end up folding I've had opponents waste burn spells picking them off and as previously mentioned they don't actually kill the tokens. Furthermore meek lurker has been way better in the sideboard  for me along side a 2 of Rams.

Bile blights kills mantis riders on the draw which is significant alongside rabbles/helps against mono aggro decka which seem to be dying out.

Ashiok, can win against possible control mirrors that may arise on top of unanswered she's always been a house.