Through the Breach

Started by Maxpayne03, April 21, 2014, 08:07:51 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Maxpayne03

My opponent cast {Through the Breach} at my end turn and put a  {Emrakul, the Aeons Torn} into play, he said that the creature will only die at my next end step. Is it true?
Same applies to {Sneak Attack}?

griffin131

No. It is sacrificed at the next end step - regardless of when that is.

MisterJH

Its sacrificed at whatever end step happens next once cast. Its a delayed trigger for the very next end step. So at the end of his turn he loses emmy

particle

Quote from: MisterJH on April 21, 2014, 08:18:30 PM
Its sacrificed at whatever end step happens next once cast. Its a delayed trigger for the very next end step. So at the end of his turn he loses emmy

well it depends. you said he cast it at the end of your turn. if it is already your endstep, then it wont trigger until the start of next endstep. so as long as you were already in your endstep, your opponent is correct.

MisterJH

Quote from: particle on April 22, 2014, 01:35:35 AM
Quote from: MisterJH on April 21, 2014, 08:18:30 PM
Its sacrificed at whatever end step happens next once cast. Its a delayed trigger for the very next end step. So at the end of his turn he loses emmy

well it depends. you said he cast it at the end of your turn. if it is already your endstep, then it wont trigger until the start of next endstep. so as long as you were already in your endstep, your opponent is correct.
I dont think so, his opponent is saying emmy will live through the next end step.
Player 1 ends his turn(OP)
Player 2 casts through the breach during the end phase to flash in emmy
It is now Player 2's turn. At the beginning of Player 2's end step would Emrakul not die? Player 2 is arguing it would survive util Player 1's next end step rather than the very next end step

rarehuntertay

Quote from: MisterJH on April 22, 2014, 07:02:44 AM
Quote from: particle on April 22, 2014, 01:35:35 AM
Quote from: MisterJH on April 21, 2014, 08:18:30 PM
Its sacrificed at whatever end step happens next once cast. Its a delayed trigger for the very next end step. So at the end of his turn he loses emmy

well it depends. you said he cast it at the end of your turn. if it is already your endstep, then it wont trigger until the start of next endstep. so as long as you were already in your endstep, your opponent is correct.
I dont think so, his opponent is saying emmy will live through the next end step.
Player 1 ends his turn(OP)
Player 2 casts through the breach during the end phase to flash in emmy
It is now Player 2's turn. At the beginning of Player 2's end step would Emrakul not die? Player 2 is arguing it would survive util Player 1's next end step rather than the very next end step

If  {Through the Breach} is cast during an end step, the delayed trigger will not happen until the start of the next end step. In your example, he cast it during his opponent's end step. The trigger on Breach will occur at the beginning of his end step, which is the next end step. He needs to read the card better lol

MisterJH

Yay go me

But in conclusion he tried to trick you(actually he probably just doesnt understand but w/e)

Its a trap!