Reverberate and Counterspells

Started by ibtrickey, January 09, 2014, 03:30:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ibtrickey

 {Reverberate}
So you could {Negate} a negate with reverberate? Correct.

Kaworu, the Fifth Child


Double-O-Scotch

#2
Just about the only thing you CAN'T {reverberate} is a {last word}

Correction : if last word is the only instant on the stack...

Pi

Also have to look out for things with split second ex {sudden shock}

Mr_Fahrenheit

Why can't you reverberate last word? It only says you can't counter it. Reverberate only copies it.

Pi

You may copy it, but cannot counter it with the copy because it cannot not be countered

Anoobass

True, but you can't counter without a target in the first place.

Pleeb

Split second is the syrup on the stack of pancakes. As long as it's there, you can't do anything. As soon as it resolves you can add to the stack again.

Giggle the Draco Genius

Quote from: Pleeb on January 10, 2014, 12:30:37 AM
Split second is the syrup on the stack of pancakes. As long as it's there, you can't do anything. As soon as it resolves you can add to the stack again.

This made me laugh harder than it should have

Skarekrow512


ibtrickey

Quote from: Skarekrow512 on January 10, 2014, 06:33:52 AM
{Wild Ricochet}?
Works sometimes...
I am trying to work a edh with  {Soul Conduit} to where I lower my life and then switch mine with theirs but I need soul conduit to not get countered.. And for soul conduit can you have you life hit zero when you tap the six mana to change life and it kill your opponent? Or no.. Confused with so many cards... I am starting to ask on here because I play with a friend and I am on here for both of us...

Gorzo

No on the soul conduit at 0 - once your life total hits 0, that's it. You're dead and gone long before you would receive priority again in order to activate the conduit's ability, let alone getting to resolve it.

ibtrickey

So you have to have at least one life when you tap the 6 mana to tap soul conduit??

Mr_Fahrenheit

Have a copy of {reverse the sands} as an alternative so if the conduit gets countered you aren't necessarily screwed.

Spencer Addington

Quote from: Gorzo on January 10, 2014, 07:12:11 AM
No on the soul conduit at 0 - once your life total hits 0, that's it. You're dead and gone long before you would receive priority again in order to activate the conduit's ability, let alone getting to resolve it.
{Platinum angel}