EDH tourney- round finals!

[particle]

can i join with my {geth, lord of the vaults} deck? no infinite combos or unfunness.

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

can i join with my {geth, lord of the vaults} deck? no infinite combos or unfunness.

Unless 2 other people volunteer themselves within a day, no, sorry.

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

I'm not against winning combos, just fun ruining ones.

It only isn't fun if your deck doesn't have an answer.  Edh decks should have every single answer you could want.  And yes, you can get to them.  Black has tutors, blue has draw, and if you chose not to run those colors, just swarm your opponent with your huge green creatures, red burn, or whatever white does.

If I were to ask if {diochan! artful beauty} would be an ok commander! you would would say yes.  Now I say if diochan plus {swift foot boots} would be allowed and seeing the rude combo, without any thought of removal, you would say no.

I would say yes to that.
And no, decks aren't fun if your opponents are complete spikes in EDH, an entirely casual for-fun format.

You just said decks aren't fun if they are as good as they can be, but regardless, those not fun decks are simply combo decks that you don't have an answer for.  If you have an answer for it, then the game is still fun.  I'm going to be done with this topic now, but I think that your "fun decks only" rule is rather lame, because with a good deck, you can dismantle any combo, and make the game fun for yourself again.

Not really. Obnoxious decks are decks that really don't let you do anything. If we can't agree on the argument lets agree to stop the argument.
...
Want to join?

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

If you want to join, Particle still wants to join, if someone else wants to join soon yes.

[Mlerner12]

I'll join with Oloro I guess

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

Yup

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

Really?  Having everything be countered or destroyed is ok?  I thought that wouldn't be ok, but hey!  I'm not going to argue.

You have a 1/99 chance of getting it.

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

I have a gagillion ways to destroy/counter everything.  And btw my commander is oloro.

Noted.

[particle]

so when does this start?

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

... It already did, did you not see your thread?

[particle]

... It already did, did you not see your thread?

sorry, yes i posted on it.

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

... It already did, did you not see your thread?

sorry, yes i posted on it.

[Kaworu, the Fifth Child]

I will be helping tricky situations be resolved as needed

[Ekann1]

what do we do if someone doesn't post for a while?

[Mlerner12]

what do we do if someone doesn't post for a while?

Have you tried PM'ing them?