I Propose A Challenge

[Birdbrain]

And I promise sense I suggested so many mechanics for white I will stay out of the other colors in suggesting mechanics

[FlickerYourOwnIdentity]

Birdbrain, I designed a mechanic for white.

Savior (Whenever a creature would die, you may sacrifice this creature instead.)


It would be on angels, and missionaries in the white color.

[Birdbrain]

Dang it...can the flicker mechanic be for blue?

The mechanic is supposed to throw lots of ETB triggers on the stack, which is crazy and has never been done before I don't think. Though I think the effects should be slightly under the curve

[FlickerYourOwnIdentity]

Oh no, I thought it as an idea.  I didn't see your idea posts sorry.  Im just throwing it in there.  Flicker could be white. :)

[Mlerner12]

Red could be
Whenever an instant or sorcery you control deals damage, you may pay {R}. If you do, {CREATURE NAME} deals three damage to target creature or player.
I think this is great for burn, but red aggro needs something different.

[Millionlittlee]

Red could be
Whenever an instant or sorcery you control deals damage, you may pay {R}. If you do, {CREATURE NAME} deals three damage to target creature or player.
I think this is great for burn, but red aggro needs something different.

I think it's a little op

[Mlerner12]

Then maybe pay {R}{R} instead?

[Iandtormentor]

Then maybe pay {R}{R} instead?

or maybe just 2 damage?

[Mlerner12]

Is it a good mechanic?

[Iandtormentor]

I like it.

[Millionlittlee]

Maybe this. My take on how it could be

When ever you cast a non creature spell put a x counter on it
When ever you cast a creature spell put a y counter on it
After you cast a spell you may pay {R}{R}{1} (this can changed based on different cards.) If you do deal x damage to target creature (or player depends on how strong we want it) and put a 1/1 goblin for each y
At the end of the turn remove all x and y counters from this card

[Birdbrain]

Maybe this. My take on how it could be

When ever you cast a non creature spell put a x counter on it
When ever you cast a creature spell put a y counter on it
After you cast a spell you may pay {R}{R}{1} (this can changed based on different cards.) If you do deal x damage to target creature (or player depends on how strong we want it) and put a 1/1 goblin for each y
At the end of the turn remove all x and y counters from this card

what happens with instances and sorceries with this?

[Millionlittlee]

Maybe this. My take on how it could be

When ever you cast a non creature spell put a x counter on it
When ever you cast a creature spell put a y counter on it
After you cast a spell you may pay {R}{R}{1} (this can changed based on different cards.) If you do deal x damage to target creature (or player depends on how strong we want it) and put a 1/1 goblin for each y
At the end of the turn remove all x and y counters from this card

what happens with instances and sorceries with this?

It's a non-creature spell so it gets an x counter

[Birdbrain]

Maybe this. My take on how it could be

When ever you cast a non creature spell put a x counter on it
When ever you cast a creature spell put a y counter on it
After you cast a spell you may pay {R}{R}{1} (this can changed based on different cards.) If you do deal x damage to target creature (or player depends on how strong we want it) and put a 1/1 goblin for each y
At the end of the turn remove all x and y counters from this card

what happens with instances and sorceries with this?

It's a non-creature spell so it gets an x counter

then it leaves the stack and goes to the graveyard? What happens to the counter?

[Iandtormentor]

Maybe this. My take on how it could be

When ever you cast a non creature spell put a x counter on it
When ever you cast a creature spell put a y counter on it
After you cast a spell you may pay {R}{R}{1} (this can changed based on different cards.) If you do deal x damage to target creature (or player depends on how strong we want it) and put a 1/1 goblin for each y
At the end of the turn remove all x and y counters from this card

what happens with instances and sorceries with this?

It's a non-creature spell so it gets an x counter

then it leaves the stack and goes to the graveyard? What happens to the counter?

I believe if we follow the rules it would cease to exist :/