Cartel aristocrat

Started by Dragonjr, June 13, 2013, 01:41:09 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Dragonjr

Okay I was in a situation where I could have won if I sacked my board to this guy but my oppenet said I could pick more than 5 colors. Is that true and here is the card  {Cartel Aristocrat}

Double-O-Scotch

There are only 5 colours. If you were to sac 5 creatures, you could give it protection from all colours. I'm not sure what you're asking though so I hope this helps.

scarsabrex

You could double/triple/gotten as many redundant protections from the same color. You could have sacced your entire board even the aristocrat itself.

Double-O-Scotch

You can't sac the cartel aristocrat to itself. It says "sacrifice another creature"

Not that you'd want to, cause protection won't save it from going to the graveyard as part of the cost, but I digress...

scarsabrex

Oops was thinking of {falkenrath aristocrat}. I assumed they had similar texts.

Dragonjr

I was just wondering if I could double up on the protections to kill my friend

Double-O-Scotch

Doubling up isn't going to change anything. Protection from red is protection from red no matter how many times you do it. Only difference would be stack tricks.

Activated abilities use the stack. Example time

You have {cartel aristocrat} and let's say 5 spirit tokens in play.  You attack your opponent. In response, you're opponent plays {lightning bolt} targeting the aristocrat. In response to that, you sac a spirit, choosing red. Now, in response to that, they lightning bolt again (aristocrat doesn't receive protection until the ability resolves). Now you can sac another spirit token and name red again and save it.

Make sense?

Dragonjr

No I'm asking if I can do it to deal the damage with  {Blood Artist} I just need to know if I can sack more than 5 times

Double-O-Scotch

A creature can only be sacrificed once. Once it is sacrificed it cannot be sacrificed again because its gone.

Double-O-Scotch

You can use cartel aristocrats ability of sacrificing creatures until you run out of creatures to sacrifice. So yes, more than 5. If you had 10 creatures plus the aristocrat, you could activate the ability 10 times. Redundant for protection but a great sac outlet.

Dragonjr

Your not understanding what I'm saying, okay can I sack 5 creatures to my aristocrat to deal him 5 damage and I gain 5 life with blood artist can I keep sacking because I have more creatures to sack to finish him off can I do that because I want to kill him with blood artist

Frothandslosh

You could sacrifice more than 5 creatures with {Cartel Aristocrat} and be able to trigger {Blood Artist}.

Dragonjr

Okay thank you I was just confused lol complicated to explain

Mikefrompluto

Quote from: Dragonjr on June 13, 2013, 03:36:34 PM
Your not understanding what I'm saying, okay can I sack 5 creatures to my aristocrat to deal him 5 damage and I gain 5 life with blood artist can I keep sacking because I have more creatures to sack to finish him off can I do that because I want to kill him with blood artist

Yes. It's also useful to list all of the cards youre using. The confusion came from the fact that you didnt mention {Blood Artist} in the original post, so no one knew what you were talking about. ;)

scarsabrex

Quote from: scarsabrex on June 13, 2013, 02:10:24 PM
You could double/triple/gotten as many redundant protections from the same color. You could have sacced your entire board even the aristocrat itself.

How does my answer not answer his question?