THIS! Is the official plane vote for the community set.

Started by FlickerYourOwnIdentity, March 22, 2013, 12:53:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

FlickerYourOwnIdentity

Right now we are making a community set, please go and read 'plane disscusions' and 'something we haven't done before...' too catch up.  Please vote fairly, right now in the runnings we have

All-Mana Mania: 0
FlickerYourOwnIdentity: 3

Please vote by saying and I quote "I vote for <insert favorite here>"

No voting for yourself.

Please inform me if I missed anybody.

Birdbrain

I vote for flickers set. And I think another person had an idea

The1337Magician

I vote flicker's set. By the way, what would all the colors represent? Green/white dryads. Red/black/blue progress?

Birdbrain

Red could represent natures ferocity. After all: Naya. Of course I think in Naya red represented natures unhindered freedom. It could mean either

The1337Magician

Red/green nature= gruul
Blue white black artificers= esper

FlickerYourOwnIdentity

Quote from: The1337Magician on March 22, 2013, 08:18:03 AM
Red/green nature= gruul
Blue white black artificers= esper
Well white could swing both ways, it's part of both.  Just to make the colors even.

FlickerYourOwnIdentity

Like white for humans is the ESPER kind of thing, and for nature they have some pegasui, and birds.  Any other creature types?

Birdbrain

Quote from: FlickerYourOwnIdentity on March 22, 2013, 09:16:38 AM
Like white for humans is the ESPER kind of thing, and for nature they have some pegasui, and birds.  Any other creature types?
for white?

MisterJH

Sorry to sidetrack but for progress why not revisit the contraptions from that one ridiculous card in future sight? It gives flexible options and fits the theme of modernization well

Birdbrain

Quote from: MisterJH on March 22, 2013, 09:27:05 AM
Sorry to sidetrack but for progress why not revisit the contraptions from that one ridiculous card in future sight? It gives flexible options and fits the theme of modernization well
contraptions could be counters and the creatures/cards could hit thresholds and gain abilities

MisterJH

Ok again not on track but i thought of this..

{B} Black is the brutality of nature, such as disease starvation and fighting for resources/territory

{G} Green represents the serenity of nature, and the wish to continue as before

{W} Angel-themed, white is divine an above the struggles of the world. White is on the fences basically, and has support for both sides as well as a single mechanic that will work for both

{R} Red represents the brutality of industry. Think back to the industrial age, where workers were stepped on to increase production and wealth.

{U} Blue represents the logical side of industry, and the benefits of advancement instead of the greedy money side.

As you can see, {B}/{G} and {R}/{U} are two sides of the same coin. Just my idea of how to make the set interesting

Birdbrain

But...angels could be...I'm kidding. I thought the colors might be able to serve multipule sides. Like innistrad, and scars of mirridon. But if this is what is decided. Although red could be ferocity or freedom of nature. Black could be selfishness of industry and grabs for power

MisterJH

Yes both of those would work just as well that jus my pick since i just learned about the industrial revolution in school recently haha

Birdbrain

Quote from: MisterJH on March 22, 2013, 02:52:49 PM
Yes both of those would work just as well that jus my pick since i just learned about the industrial revolution in school recently haha
i can see how the industrial revelation is izzet colored. It's the era steampunk harkens back to. An izzet is kinda steampunk. Also, uninhibited advances in technology seems very {U}{R}

MisterJH