Counter replicate, storm

[Mullaney413]

What happens when you counter a spell that has replicate,are all copies countered or just the first?  What happens when you counter a spell with storm are all copies countered or just the first?

[BlackJester]

Good question!  I'm fairly sure that both abilities set up a triggered effect.  Even if you counter the original spell, the trigger will use the last known information and still create the copies.  The only ways to counter this is some {Stiffle}-like effect, or counter the whole stack like {Swift Silence} of {Time Stop}.

Can anyone else confirm this?

[Rass]

Can anyone else confirm this?

I would ask blackjester

[Mullaney413]

Black jester is the one who asked for confirmation.

[BlackJester]

Can anyone else confirm this?

I would ask blackjester

Every time I ask myself I just end up arguing.  Then it descends into a yellin match. I always lose the debate and i just give myself the silent treatment for a couple of days. 😷

[Validan]

Sounds like a bad relationship


Can anyone else confirm this?

I would ask blackjester

Every time I ask myself I just end up arguing.  Then it descends into a yellin match. I always lose the debate and i just give myself the silent treatment for a couple of days. 😷

[BlackJester]

Sounds like a bad relationship


Can anyone else confirm this?

I would ask blackjester

Every time I ask myself I just end up arguing.  Then it descends into a yellin match. I always lose the debate and i just give myself the silent treatment for a couple of days. 😷

I don't really see eye-to-eye with myself.  I find it's just easier to avoid to much contact.