Prolly a dumb question.

Started by Calebestes, November 06, 2012, 06:33:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Calebestes

Okay I thought about throwing in a chromatic lantern or two specifically just to cast a nicol bolas in my Bant deck.  What do you think?

Anphem

In Bant, no. In UW control, you can, but you will need 4 lanterns. We tested this combo with  {Door to Nothingness},   {Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker} and  {Jace, Memory Adept}. Works good with all type of decks. Only Agro goldfish can beat it fast, in another situations we have all answers.

Wally

With axebane defender guy, lots of mana ramp along with lantern you could probably cast anything. Just don't get caught out with off colored cards in you hand when you still need more fixing.

Calebestes

So why couldn't you in Bant?  4 lanterns and a 2 nicol bolas with the draw power of Bant

Hunteroffire9

Quote from: Calebestes on November 06, 2012, 08:02:22 AM
So why couldn't you in Bant?  4 lanterns and a 2 nicol bolas with the draw power of Bant

Nicol bolas is not made for Bant he is for grixis control

Greg54js

Why would you put a planeswalker out of their element? Bolas should be in straight control builds not aggro control builds

Calebestes

Where is it written that you can't play nicol bolas in whatever the hell you want?    Is it a law?  Lol.

Guitello

Quote from: Calebestes on November 06, 2012, 08:06:55 PM
Where is it written that you can't play nicol bolas in whatever the hell you want?    Is it a law?  Lol.
It's not so much a law as a guideline as to where certain plainswalkers actually work well, for example, using Tamiyo in a UW Human Aggro list is absurdly bad

Coffee Vampire

Also, using tibalt in a deck is bad.

Calebestes

Rivals ever is bad.  Okay you are using a control plainswalker in a control deck.  Am I missing something here?

Greg54js

Quote from: Calebestes on November 07, 2012, 12:00:58 AM
Rivals ever is bad.  Okay you are using a control plainswalker in a control deck.  Am I missing something here?
Yes the control deck he's trying to put bolas into is bant. Not even grixis

Calebestes

So why is that wrong?  Why is bolas in a Bant deck wrong?

Kerebrus

#12
Quote from: Calebestes on November 07, 2012, 06:50:22 AM
So why is that wrong?  Why is bolas in a Bant deck wrong?

I can only imagine it would slow the deck down, bolas is like a 7 cast right? Even with those lanterns I feel like you could always add in {thragtusks} instead if you don't have them. When I made a Bant deck and when I had all the essentials there really wasn't much room for other cards that didn't help me win faster. Lets say turn 1 {temple garden}, {avacyns pilgrim}. Turn two {glacial fortress}, {chromatic lantern}? I'm don't think that's as good as a turn three {loxodon smiter} with a {silverblade paladin} and a {rancor} coming turn 4

Nadrojnosreppe

Yeah, I thought bolas was enough of a bad mofo that no matter the deck, his presence can change games. Some maybe more than others, but always welcome.

Kerebrus

Quote from: Nadrojnosreppe on November 07, 2012, 08:29:43 AM
Yeah, I thought bolas was enough of a bad mofo that no matter the deck, his presence can change games. Some maybe more than others, but always welcome.

Lol well he would probably come as a huge surprise for an unprepared opponent, could be a good advantage I suppose