New bannings

Started by Greg54js, September 19, 2012, 05:29:29 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Greg54js

So we have some new bannings and unbannings this morning..

{Kokusho, the evening star} now able to be used just not as a commander

{primeval Titan} BANNED.
Thank god. I hate this guy in commander

{worldfire} BANNED.

Fenster


Gorzo


Phat Max

The bannings make sense to me.

{Worldifre} couldn't stop someone from just recasting commander after it resolved. Plus it's just not fun 90% of the time.

{Primeval Titan}... Did your deck have green? Then he was in it. The amount of tutoring coming out of a single card is quite ridiculous, so I can't say I blame them for that ban. Whether you agree or not, he was very oppresive if he came down turn 6 even, let alone earlier.

Gorzo

Quote from: Phat Max on September 19, 2012, 08:35:41 AM
The bannings make sense to me.

{Worldifre} couldn't stop someone from just recasting commander after it resolved. Plus it's just not fun 90% of the time.

{Primeval Titan}... Did your deck have green? Then he was in it. The amount of tutoring coming out of a single card is quite ridiculous, so I can't say I blame them for that ban. Whether you agree or not, he was very oppresive if he came down turn 6 even, let alone earlier.

Yeah, they make sense. Worldfire exiles your lands, but you commander is like 1 card in your hand that cannot be exiled. And prime time is pretty ridonkulous.

I'm more upset about the unbanning of Kokusho, honestly. It is going to be a staple in every black deck now, and reanimate decks will abuse the crap out of it. Kokusho -belonged- on that banned list.

AgrusKos

My cousin told me why Kokusho was good, and I decided not to put it back in Jarad for the safety of my peersand the price,

Phat Max

I like how graveyard hate was the reason they unbanned...

Cause people have sideboards for Commander, and play 3 game matches, am I right?

Elitehalo360

Wtf p titty what did he do?? Like yes I ran him but he's not over powered by any means and I had two deck that stole other Ppls primals for me D:

Greg54js

Quote from: Elitehalo360 on September 19, 2012, 11:34:45 AM
Wtf p titty what did he do?? Like yes I ran him but he's not over powered by any means and I had two deck that stole other Ppls primals for me D:
When all your running is non basics... This guy tends to be a boss and if you have green anywhere on your commander your deff running this guy.

Elitehalo360

Quote from: Greg54js on September 19, 2012, 12:39:57 PM
Quote from: Elitehalo360 on September 19, 2012, 11:34:45 AM
Wtf p titty what did he do?? Like yes I ran him but he's not over powered by any means and I had two deck that stole other Ppls primals for me D:
When all your running is non basics... This guy tends to be a boss and if you have green anywhere on your commander your deff running this guy.
Still not overpowered  for it to be banned imho

Greg54js

Well if he's used right, he can be insane with a landfall deck. There are also other decks that profit from his ability. He's just insane across the board

Juggalonoke


Gorzo


Greg54js

Quote from: Juggalonoke on September 19, 2012, 03:37:08 PM
Prof link please!?
For the bannings?

Mtgcommander.net  under rules

Juggalonoke