Resolving

Started by cltrn81, July 03, 2012, 03:04:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

cltrn81

Ok opponent had a 1/2 {tarmogoyf} with 1 land in the GY.  I cast {shock} and target goyf.  Is the goyf a 2/3 before the spell resolves or will the 2 damage be able to kill it before my card enters the GY?

BlackJester

{Shock} deals it's damage "during" resolution and then Shock goes to the gy.  It is in the gy when the game state is checked and will contribute to the 'goyf's P/T.  It lives.

cltrn81


scarsabrex

Quote from: BlackJester on July 03, 2012, 03:10:10 PM
{Shock} deals it's damage "during" resolution and then Shock goes to the gy.  It is in the gy when the game state is checked and will contribute to the 'goyf's P/T.  It lives.

this

BadLuckIrish

this why in a puzzle on DotP13 {Rite of Replecation} the 'bring an instant or socrey to hand' guy the rite that u casted is in the GY WHILE you are choosing?

BlackJester

Quote from: BadLuckIrish on July 04, 2012, 01:52:03 PM
this why in a puzzle on DotP13 {Rite of Replecation} the 'bring an instant or socrey to hand' guy the rite that u casted is in the GY WHILE you are choosing?
Wha? 

scarsabrex

he's talking about archaeomancer. the trigger doesn't appear until after rites has resolved and gone to the grave. so rites is a valid target.

BlackJester

Quote from: scarsabrex on July 04, 2012, 03:18:21 PM
he's talking about archaeomancer. the trigger doesn't appear until after rites has resolved and gone to the grave. so rites is a valid target.
Right, because the {Archaeomancer} has an ETB trigger, so Rites must have finished resolving before their triggers get Stacked.