Infect and Undying

[Silent1236]

My friend had a {Strangleroot Geist} out, and I killed it and the Undying activated.  Then, next turn, he attacks with it again.  I block with my 2/2 infect, does the -1/-1 counter remove the +1/+1 or does it make it so the Geist has 1 +1/+1 and 2 -1/-1's?  Would the undying trigger again or would the Geist die?

[Millionlittlee]

Undying triggers again

[scarsabrex]

geist dies for good.

[Millionlittlee]

I call for jester

[Silent1236]

Which is it?  lol

[Kuberr]

I agree with scars. It would kill it.

[scarsabrex]

rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.

[Silent1236]

It would remove the +1/+1 then add a -1/-1. Which would reduce the toughness to 0 and destroy it. Then undying would trigger again.

It would come back because of undying.  It just says "When this creature dies."  So putting a -1/-1 on it would still "kill" it, would it not?

[Silent1236]

rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.

Awesome!  Thanks!

[scarsabrex]

rule 704.7 to correct those who disagree with me.

and for those who fail to read

[Millionlittlee]

I win

[Rokitchikin]

Retract all previous statements thanks scars.

[scarsabrex]

I win

you called jester... I answered. you most certainly did not win.

[Millionlittlee]

I said it first and I called jester because I didn't know the rule number

[Quackmaster5]

I win

you called jester... I answered. you most certainly did not win.

Ya the rule is saying that you are wrong. So I don't see that as a win