Mafia Day 2 Time to lynch!

[BadLuckIrish]

O.o what i do that a drunken Irishman had to die? T.T

[Gorzo]

Really? They chose Irish? That's...not what I expected.

Some interesting points brought up. The doctor call I'm not really sure about. It is a little fishy, but I can see where he's coming from. He is the only one with any experience, so I can see why he'd seek protection - id see that as threatening. I can see the strategy behing asking for a doctor, but getting one or not is another story.

Sage I dunno about. He is quite quick to vote for the current "hot topic" to lynch, which really does look like he doesn't care who dies, any townie will do, which is pretty fishy.

Jace looks suspicious to me too. Comes in extremely fast to vote, and changes his vote quick, which also raises that "anyone other than me and my mafia pals will do" red flag for me.

[BadLuckIrish]

I cant throw up arguments can i?

[Sagemaster]

Whoa whoa whoa, you guys ever take a history class or watch pirates of the Caribbean? Peasants don't care who die as long as its not them...same with villagers IMO. But I guess I did being myself the limelight I'll be more cautious if there's a next time haha

[Sagemaster]

Also calling everyone he votes for scum...makes me think that he's the mafia and as soon as the finger was pointed his way he directed it back..

[Sagemaster]

I would also like to point out that this is the second time I've followed JaCe. First with coffee now proph but each time proph has voted me...not JaCe, porque? I'm thinking coffee and proph are mafia but not sure of who the third could be...not JaCe cause why would he vote proph if they were both mafia...also I was making a joke by saying hay wagon instead of band wagon haha

[Coffee Vampire]

You bring up some valid points, Gorzo, and they should be considered. However, after re-reading the posts, I noticed something. You were the only one I noticed who tried to cast suspicion on the late Irish. I acknowledge that this may be coincidence, but I cannot ignore the parallel here. I would like to bring this point forth for consideration as well.

I also noticed this, which is why I put him on my suspicion list. Another thing I noticed about Gorzo was that he said that I deserve to live. It was in a joking tone, but I took note that someone who has the ability to kill people will be more likely to say that someone else "deserves to live". It may br nothing but who knows.

[BlackJester]

I haven't really been paying attention, but is all this part of the game?   

[Sagemaster]

I haven't really been paying attention, but is all this part of the game?   

Yea most of it haha

[Gorzo]

I am deeply saddened... I was actually being serious when I said I wanted you to live. I believe you are a townie, and we need our fellow townies to live if we want to beat the mafia. That's why we cant just bandwagon vote.

As for Irish, I only mentioned him more to get a rise out of him since he hadn't said much since voting (I lol'd at that coffee comment btw), and wanted more people to get involved. Didn't want him dead. It would also draw attention straight to myself to kill him, as the only person who showed suspicion of him. Maybe that's why they chose him, thought they could get a free Gorzo-lynch out of it. 2-for-1.

[Gorzo]

I haven't really been paying attention, but is all this part of the game?   

Haha yes, it is. All a game, fighting for our lives, avoiding the noose in the day and the baddies at night. You should join next go-around perhaps. It's be fun seeing who tries to lynch Jester!

[Sagemaster]

I was just getting into character by bandwagonning.. Watch I think it's the 4th pirates where everyone is yelling hang him hang him haha

[Thorn]

Well personnaly I think Irish had a special role. Why? Because he didnt post here very much at all.  I knew I havent posted much either but I have re-re-re-read these 13 pages and I know whats going on. So fellow townies I would like to bring that point into play.
By the way. Milo where is the name and position of the investigators search?

[darkarts981]

I suspect
Sagemaster - for being so quick to vote proph
Prophylaxis - simply because he is so into the investigation that it could be a ploy to divert attention from him

[Thorn]

I was just getting into character by bandwagonning.. Watch I think it's the 4th pirates where everyone is yelling hang him hang him haha

I agree with darkarts ^^, Sagemaster now seems to be trying shrink the severity of his post. Like he knows he made a mistake and now wants to back out from his descion. I think it is very plausible that sage is a mafia.
But then... Darkarts did acuse him...
So darkarts could be distracting us from himself while he plots more murders! He could be mafia to!!!
Just throwing my thoughts out there