Powerful Commanders?

[Thetrufflehunter]

Hello!

I'm planning on building a second commander deck once I finish Tiny Leaders and Legacy, and I'm deciding what sort of deck.

My current thoughts are:
Sigarda Voltron
Memnarch Control
The Mimeoplasm Combo
Kruphix Ramp

Commanders I DON'T want to run:
Kaalia
Animar
Ghave

And the last thing is I'd prefer not to play Esper or pillow fort. That's what Oloro is for

VOTES:

Edric - 1

[Kaalia with haste]

For power level give Edric a shot. He's who I play despite my name. A bunch of 1/1 fliers for 1 CMC are phyrexian arenas in that deck, then toss in some cheap counterspells that cost 2 or less. Add triumph of the hordes, beast master ascension and champion of lambholt and some fast mana. After that you're good to go.

[Spencer Addington]

Competetive or multiplayer? Combo or creature? Preferred color?

[Thetrufflehunter]

Competetive or multiplayer? Combo or creature? Preferred color?

Hopefully not losing either category, but multiplayer. Either combo or creature, but not ridiculous fast combo. Color preferences is just not esper.

OP updated.

[Kaalia with haste]

Competetive or multiplayer? Combo or creature? Preferred color?

Hopefully not losing either category, but multiplayer. Either combo or creature, but not ridiculous fast combo. Color preferences is just not esper.

OP updated.

Edric is combo and creature so good in 1v1 they banned him in French and ridiculously feared in multiplayer.

[Thetrufflehunter]

Also thinking of Kruphix ramp...

[DimirOverlord1300]

Or

Derevi.

Seriously though there's a lot of REALLY good primers and Decklists out there (if you want me to link some I can), and she's really strong. If you want a powerful deck UG is where you want to be, and Edric or Derevi are probably your best options, maybe The Mimeoplasm in there too. I don't think Kruphix accurately would portray the power of UG decks in the format.

[Thetrufflehunter]

Or

Derevi.

Seriously though there's a lot of REALLY good primers and Decklists out there (if you want me to link some I can), and she's really strong. If you want a powerful deck UG is where you want to be, and Edric or Derevi are probably your best options, maybe The Mimeoplasm in there too. I don't think Kruphix accurately would portray the power of UG decks in the format.

Read a Mimeoplasm primer. I'm kind of in love

I think right now its Edric or Plasm.

[DimirOverlord1300]

Or

Derevi.

Seriously though there's a lot of REALLY good primers and Decklists out there (if you want me to link some I can), and she's really strong. If you want a powerful deck UG is where you want to be, and Edric or Derevi are probably your best options, maybe The Mimeoplasm in there too. I don't think Kruphix accurately would portray the power of UG decks in the format.

Read a Mimeoplasm primer. I'm kind of in love

I think right now its Edric or Plasm.

I'd take a look at a derevi primer, either the one by Glix on tappedout.net or the one by Swift on mtgsalvation. She's pretty great.

[Kaalia with haste]

Or

Derevi.

Seriously though there's a lot of REALLY good primers and Decklists out there (if you want me to link some I can), and she's really strong. If you want a powerful deck UG is where you want to be, and Edric or Derevi are probably your best options, maybe The Mimeoplasm in there too. I don't think Kruphix accurately would portray the power of UG decks in the format.

Read a Mimeoplasm primer. I'm kind of in love

I think right now its Edric or Plasm.

My main issue with plasm is the fragility of it. People will run rest in peace if your deck gets out of hand. Edric supposedly loses to wrath of god but the only board wipe that can REALLY slow down Edric is supreme verdict. Note that I say slow down and not stop because nothing stops him.

[Thetrufflehunter]

Or

Derevi.

Seriously though there's a lot of REALLY good primers and Decklists out there (if you want me to link some I can), and she's really strong. If you want a powerful deck UG is where you want to be, and Edric or Derevi are probably your best options, maybe The Mimeoplasm in there too. I don't think Kruphix accurately would portray the power of UG decks in the format.

Read a Mimeoplasm primer. I'm kind of in love

I think right now its Edric or Plasm.

My main issue with plasm is the fragility of it. People will run rest in peace if your deck gets out of hand. Edric supposedly loses to wrath of god but the only board wipe that can REALLY slow down Edric is supreme verdict. Note that I say slow down and not stop because nothing stops him.

Do you have a list? You make a good point with RIP.

[MuggyWuggy]

Scion is the bomv

[Spencer Addington]

Scion is awesome. Made my sliver Broverlord drck instead because I though it would be fun to play against my friends slivers with my own lol. I say {sliver overlord} should be your next commander. Have a pretty good list if you want to take a look see, but there are probably better lists.

[Munchlax]

I know you said not Animar but creature AND combo makes him the best choice.

{Surrak Dragonclaw} can make your combo pieces uncounterable. Good general

{Alesha Who Smiles At Death} makes a good combo/synergistic general with ETB/LTB abilities. This is my cruel multiplayer deck.

{Riku something Reflection} is a good combo/control/value deck

{Zedruu the Greathearted} can be pure jank but is a wonderful multiplayer general

{Zur the Enchanter} gets hate But is a good combo general

Five colour {Enduring Ideal} combo is a wonderful deck. There's one on this site under Atogatog in the community deck spotlight

{Muzzio, Visionary Architect} is a combo general that gets really explosive turns

{Sharuum the Hegemon} is one of the best combo generals out there.

{Nekusar the Mindrazer} is rediculous. A really good deck

{Titania Protector of Argoth} ditches lands for dudes.

{Krenko Mob Boss} is a really good tribal/ combo deck

{Narset Enlightened Master} is obvious

{Tajic Blade of the Legion} aggro/infinite attack phases.

{Melek Izzet Paragon} is an all in storm deck

{Bruna, Light Alabastar} is Azorious enchants and instant commander kill

Those are all my favourite generals or just the best I've seen

[Thetrufflehunter]

Now it's a tossup between Zedruu, Mimeoplasm, Edric, and legacy