Mistveil plains and fetches

Started by Anoobass, September 08, 2014, 08:12:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Anoobass

I don't think it will work, but figured it was worth asking.

If I have a {windswept Heath} and {mistveil plains} on the battlefield, both untapped (as well as 2 white creatures to allow the ability of the plains).  I choose to sac and fetch a regular forest.  Is there any chance between the Heath hitting the graveyard and shuffling in which I can activate the mistveil plains to tuck the Heath on the bottom to be shuffled in from it's own ability?

particle

Quote from: Anoobass on September 08, 2014, 08:12:04 PM
I don't think it will work, but figured it was worth asking.

If I have a {windswept Heath} and {mistveil plains} on the battlefield, both untapped.  I choose to sac and fetch a regular forest.  Is there any chance between the Heath hitting the graveyard and shuffling in which I can activate the mistveil plains to tuck the Heath on the bottom to be shuffled in from it's own ability?

nope. players will not get priority while spells or abilities are mid-resolving. you will have to wait for the fetch ability to fully resolve before you can take any actions (other than floating mana}.

particle

why did my page get all quoted? i didnt quote it. mods?!?!

particle

this page is all screwed! sorry wont even let me edit my posts.

Anoobass

U broke it... I hope you're happy...

particle


Anoobass

Anyway, thanks for answering, I figured that was the case but wanted to be sure :), I'd +1 but u broke it...

Ekann1


Remillo

Since you sacrifice the Heath as part of the cost to its ability, you can respond to the ability by tucking with Mistveil Plains.  It works like you want it to (Just remember that you can use the land you fetch to pay for it and still have it shuffled in)

Anoobass

The reason I don't think you can though is because there is no break in the ability on {windswept Heath}.  It's just 1 long ability.  I would think that maybe you could if it read:

"
{T}, pay 1 life, sacrifice ~~~~: search...onto the battlefield

Shuffle your library.
"

Could I get a guaranteed 100% response?

particle

sorry remillo is right i blew up the thread and was wrong. sorry everyone. misread the question. so you pay the life sac the fetch, and the search trigger goes on the stack. in response, you can activate {mistveil plains} and put the fetch back in the library.

Anoobass

So before the search trigger goes on the stack I have to use the plains ability?

particle

no. you activate fetch ability. that trigger goes on the stack. before you pass priority you respond to that trigger by activating {mistveil plains}. by that point the fetch land is in your yard so it can be returned.

Anoobass


Destore117

Oh god! It's coffeevampire all over again! (Can't remember when but I know what you did >.> )