Ban List Discussion (speculation)

[MacheteMable]

Yes, unban {second sunrise} plz.  There's plenty of graveyard hate.

won't be unbanned for the same reason (Sensei's Divining Top) won't be unbanned. Time. Eggs extended the time tournaments took because people would go to time. Most of the time spent in each round was solely during the eggs players turns and mainly the turn they went off. There was a big issue during the gps after the pro tour that was one by eggs.

[MacheteMable]

If the opponent has graveyard hate (like {relic of progenitous}). Their turn don't take very long because they get stopped.

I know it won't happen, but I can hope.

that doesn't work very well though. They can fight through it most of the time. Thst deck made our Wednesday night modern go waaaaay too long.

[MacheteMable]

Not really.  They just hope to draw good stuff to try it again.

considering so much of the deck cantrips for free it was quite easy.

I want {preordain} or {ponder} unbanned

[Mattao19]

Not really.  They just hope to draw good stuff to try it again.

considering so much of the deck cantrips for free it was easy.

I want (preordain) unbanned. Or (ponder)

Preordain and Ponder are broken in modern ... With the fetchlands you can completely manipulate your deck.

[lotrwk]

while we're at it, lets unban {sensei's diving top}!  Lego miracles without the force of will or awesome lands!

And jace and sfm....

[lotrwk]

Forgot jace, but miracles doesn't run {stone forge mystic}

Brian Braun duin has been playing miracles for 5 months and plays sfm as a one of

[blackychan1]

Let's ban {tarmogoyf} just to screw with Jund players.

[Munchlax]

Let's ban {tarmogoyf} just to screw with Jund players.

And every other green deck and force their value to plummet and enrage many many players who will just stop playing modern and screw with that market. They wouldn't do that

[MacheteMable]

I could get behind tarmogoyf banning. When a card gets put into decks that it has no business being in. Affinity. Splinter twin. Then we gots a problem yo.

[DeathlyFoiend]

I could get behind tarmogoyf banning. When a card gets put into decks that it has no business being in. Affinity. Splinter twin. Then we gots a problem yo.

Why?

[Mattao19]

Tarmo is not broken though sure he's good but it's not like he's hard to deal with and if you SB in GY hate he's an 0/1 ... It's not hard to deal with him. Having said that he's a great creature but certainly not broken!

[MacheteMable]

Tarmo is not broken though sure he's good but it's not like he's hard to deal with and if you SB in GY hate he's an 0/1 ... It's not hard to deal with him. Having said that he's a great creature but certainly not broken!

I didn't say he was broken. Afterall he's just a vanilla creature. I could just see a ban for diversities sake

[cltrn81]

Tarmo is not broken though sure he's good but it's not like he's hard to deal with and if you SB in GY hate he's an 0/1 ... It's not hard to deal with him. Having said that he's a great creature but certainly not broken!

I didn't say he was broken. Afterall he's just a vanilla creature. I could just see a ban for diversities sake

Won't happen IMHO

[Agrus Kos, Enforcer of Truth]

Tarmo is not broken though sure he's good but it's not like he's hard to deal with and if you SB in GY hate he's an 0/1 ... It's not hard to deal with him. Having said that he's a great creature but certainly not broken!

I didn't say he was broken. Afterall he's just a vanilla creature. I could just see a ban for diversities sake

I kind of have to agree. The card isn't broken, but banning him would lead to more diversity and a more interesting format.

[Mattao19]

Diversity? Just bc twin plays it doesn't mean anything. DRS was banned bc Burn played it lol BURN lol but Tarmo is not hurting modern at all sure (s)he wins games but it's not like if your deck doesn't run him you're effed