Floating mana

Started by Avodroc13, May 17, 2014, 08:13:14 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Avodroc13

Floating nana is something I recently learned on here, my question is, if I were to cast {Armageddon} could my opponent float mana?
Say I wanted to {Faith's Reward} afterwards, could they float enough mana for {Counterspell}? Or am I understanding the whole "Float mana" thing wrong?

Remillo

Quote from: Avodroc13 on May 17, 2014, 08:13:14 PM
Floating nana is something I recently learned on here, my question is, if I were to cast {Armageddon} could my opponent float mana?
Say I wanted to {Faith's Reward} afterwards, could they float enough mana for {Counterspell}? Or am I understanding the whole "Float mana" thing wrong?

Sure.  Floating mana just means you've used a mana ability without using it to pay for anything yet.  Your opponent can do this just as easily as you can.

Splicer

Couldn't he wait until the next phase though, to cast it while his opponent lost the floating mana. Unless he was floating too...

Remillo

Quote from: Splicer on May 17, 2014, 09:07:17 PM
Couldn't he wait until the next phase though, to cast it while his opponent lost the floating mana. Unless he was floating too...
In this situation, he's floated the mana to cast Faith's Reward.  If he goes to the next step or phase to make his opponent lose their UU, he'll lose his mana, too.

Splicer

And this is why we use cluestones

Remillo

Quote from: Splicer on May 17, 2014, 09:11:00 PM
And this is why we use cluestones

Pssh, the only Cluestone I run is because of the Draw ability as an extra fallback for if five million things happen when trying to win off of Laboratory Maniac

Splicer

#6
L{aboratory maniac} is awesome, but there is something he cannot best.

{Storm Crow}!!!

Double-O-Scotch

Quote from: Splicer on May 17, 2014, 09:37:53 PM
Laboratory maniac is awesome, but there is something he cannot best.

{Storm Crow}!!!

On the contrary, if they fought, lab maniac would best him. Done deal.

Splicer

Only in a fight of brute force.

Avodroc13

Is land brought back to the battlefield tapped, or untapped by {Faith's Reward}?

Ekann1

Quote from: Avodroc13 on May 18, 2014, 04:00:43 PM
Is land brought back to the battlefield tapped, or untapped by {Faith's Reward}?
Depends on the land. Since it doesn't say otherwise, it enters how it would normally enter. Basics normally enter untapped, guildgates enter tapped. It's like they're entering the battlefield normally.

MuggyWuggy

Just so it's clear:

Mana pool empties at end of each phase.

You cast Armageddon - destroy all lands

Response - opponent taps all lands to float mana, you do the same

Armageddon resolves; destroy all lands

-------here's where your question happens -----

Faiths reward paid for with floating mana

Opponent uses floating mana for counterspell

Faiths reward is countered if you have no response