What were you expecting?

[CommanderUnderSorin]

Was playing against esper control, I was tapped out except for one swamp. He swung with  {Ætherling}, tapping all of his mana to make unblockable, and an 8/1. He did this because what possible 1 mana black spell couldn't kill his all mighty ætherling
Tapped my one mana,  {Eye Gouge}
He scooped.

[CommanderUnderSorin]

What silly situations you were in, which you thought you were winning and your opponent plays the silliest spell?

[FreddyFlash]

I like Eye Gouge, it kills mutavault

[MuggyWuggy]

I like plasma capture T4 stormbreath or another 5 drop into t5 aetherling with mana open

[FustyDavorite]

I've killed a cyclops with eye gouge before. One of the more satisfying moments of my life

[particle]

I like plasma capture T4 stormbreath or another 5 drop into t5 aetherling with mana open

if your casting {stormbreath dragon} on turn 4, how do you still have {plasm capture} mana available to get a t5 {aetherling}?

[MuggyWuggy]

Uh no I plasm captured my opponents storm breath, getting 5 floating my t5, I drop aetherling with several blue open

I've had the pleasure of capturing:
Blood baron
Obzedat
Sphinx rev
Desecration demon
Gary
Xenagos
Elspeth

It's really such a wonderful counter