question about commander

[imFourth of Phils]

based on the first text of {Phage the Untouchable}

do i lose if i cast her from command zone? thanks

[MisterJH]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

[imFourth of Phils]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

hahahaha, thanks, was just wondering in that case, but i guess ill put her in deck instead, thanks

[The1337Magician]

As a commander, yes you lose.
BUT
I have seen a  {Sundial of the Infinite} deck using her as a commander. Pretty op.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

As a commander, yes you lose.
BUT
I have seen a  {Sundial of the Infinite} deck using her as a commander. Pretty op.

{Platinum Angel} works too.

[MisterJH]

As a commander, yes you lose.
BUT
I have seen a  {Sundial of the Infinite} deck using her as a commander. Pretty op.

Wut? Wouldnt you still lose since she still must enter the battlefield? I thought itd be a statebased action that doesnt use the stack

Im not trying to be argumentative im just trying to better understand the game

[Brawler_1337]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

Yes, you do lose the game if you cast her from the command zone. Yes, there are ways to circumvent this.

No, he hasn't quite found the worst commander ever, IMHO. That title, in my book, goes to {Haakon, Stromgald Scourge}.

[MisterJH]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

Yes, you do lose the game if you cast her from the command zone. Yes, there are ways to circumvent this.

No, he hasn't quite found the worst commander ever, IMHO. That title, in my book, goes to {Haakon, Stromgald Scourge}.

Touché, thats literally 100% useless.. Congrats to you haha

[imFourth of Phils]

{Torpor Orb} i guess

[Sardok]

As a commander, yes you lose.
BUT
I have seen a  {Sundial of the Infinite} deck using her as a commander. Pretty op.

Wut? Wouldnt you still lose since she still must enter the battlefield? I thought itd be a statebased action that doesnt use the stack

Im not trying to be argumentative im just trying to better understand the game

Phage's ability that causes you to lose the game will trigger when you cast her from the command zone. This is then placed on the stack.

You then use {Sundial of the Infinite} to end the turn and exile this ability from the stack.

[Sparkle Ninja]

If this weren't commander I'd say {Time Stop}+{Phage The Untouchable} for the same thing as Sundial because its funnier and less mana efficient. Thats how I roll

[MuggyWuggy]

{Torpor Orb} i guess

Then haste and unblockable lol

[InfinitiveDivinity]

{Torpor Orb} i guess

Then haste and unblockable lol

{Hall of the Bandit Lord} + {Shizo, Death's Storehouse}/{Rogue's Passage}.

[Double-O-Scotch]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

Yes, you do lose the game if you cast her from the command zone. Yes, there are ways to circumvent this.

No, he hasn't quite found the worst commander ever, IMHO. That title, in my book, goes to {Haakon, Stromgald Scourge}.

Touché, thats literally 100% useless.. Congrats to you haha

I have to say that honour is a toss up between him and {general Jarkeld}

[DYMongoose]

Preliminary answer: based on the text id say yes indeed, anyone with more knowledge feel free to correct or support my answer


I think you may have found the worst possible commander ever o.o

Yes, you do lose the game if you cast her from the command zone. Yes, there are ways to circumvent this.

No, he hasn't quite found the worst commander ever, IMHO. That title, in my book, goes to {Haakon, Stromgald Scourge}.

Touché, thats literally 100% useless.. Congrats to you haha

I have to say that honour is a toss up between him and {general Jarkeld}

If that's a toss-up, I assume {Norin the Wary} is in the mix as well?