about commanders color

Started by imFourth of Phils, February 22, 2014, 09:50:55 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

imFourth of Phils

can i use {Progenitus} or any other 5 color Legend for commander but i only need 2 colors of it?

thanks

Double-O-Scotch

Yes you can. I wouldn't recommend it, but nothing is stopping you.

Sparkle Ninja

Well Yes. As long as the cards are in the commander's colour identity they can be played in it's deck

imFourth of Phils

thanks, cuz ive been thinking combos with the commander and cards, thanks again

Double-O-Scotch

Just remember, the colours of your commander limit the cards you can use in your deck. A mono-white commander's "colour identity" limits you to mono-white cards.  A 5-colour commander limits nothing, so go to town. I must admit, I'm quite curious about your idea...

particle

this doesnt seem like a terrible idea. ive lost many games to {hive mind} and any pact {pact of negation}, but if just thrown in a chromatic lantern, you will be immune to that.

Sparkle Ninja

I'm pretty sure {Hive Mind} with {Curse of Echoes} is infinite...

Sardok

Quote from: Sparkle Ninja on February 22, 2014, 10:49:27 PM
I'm pretty sure {Hive Mind} with {Curse of Echoes} is infinite...

Unfortunately, copying a spell is not the same as casting a spell.

{Hive Mind} and {Curse of Echoes} will each trigger once per spell cast, but it is not infinite.

Of course, the exceptions are spells like {Whispering Madness} with the "Cipher" keyword. This is because ciphering a spell means to "cast a copy" of it.

Sparkle Ninja


imFourth of Phils

Quote from: Double-O-Scotch on February 22, 2014, 10:14:26 PM
Just remember, the colours of your commander limit the cards you can use in your deck. A mono-white commander's "colour identity" limits you to mono-white cards.  A 5-colour commander limits nothing, so go to town. I must admit, I'm quite curious about your idea...

im still thinking, the weird idea came out, when i want a {U} and {R} commander and i want a {Gilder Bairn} and {Vexing Shusher} on it, im still thinking a perfect or a good fit between commander and the deck :¥

Jlamb5

Quote from: particle on February 22, 2014, 10:39:55 PM
this doesnt seem like a terrible idea. ive lost many games to {hive mind} and any pact {pact of negation}, but if just thrown in a chromatic lantern, you will be immune to that.

You still can't cast the copy of the pact, unless it's within your commanders colors. If any land would produce mana outside your commanders colors, it produces colorless mana instead. Unfortunately being victim to hive mind sucks.