A matter of right and wrong

[Wingnut]

Man be honest and make sure the trade is fair. Then you don't have to worry about it, you have no worries.

[Apathy Reactor]

Give him a fair price, he will probably think it's a steal, but as long as the trade is of close value and he is happy with it, go for it. (And you should probably ask him if he remembers where he got them, to be sure they aren't the possession of a sibling or parent)

[Necromancerman]

Ill try

[ApexPredator]

If you have to ask then its generally morally wrong.

[ApexPredator]

If you have to ask then its generally morally wrong.

*You came in like a (moral and ethical) wrecking ball*

Lmao!!!  +1 good sir

[Raiderrob]

If square corners they are just collectors edition

Black border would either be the duel deck which is rare (newer art) otherwise beta or alpha. If things are beta/alpha you better bet that whosever collection that really belongs to will come back for it.

This is why if you save nice things for your kids, wait till they are 35

i thought alpha and beta had sharper corners. I know for a fact there different somehow

They do but I believe the CE versions are just straight cut like baseball cards, believe alpha and beta still had some curvature

I just highly doubt some kid is rolling around with 3 alpha or beta demonic tutors and has no idea the value of them or significance. Whoever would have saved those for 20 years wouldnt just blindly give them to a child to take to school with.

CE looks the same in the front, but has the regular magic back with a gold border around it. Here's a pic.
http://twitter.com/raiderrob071/status/433214569444421632/photo/1

My advice is tell him what he has, and what they are worth.

[Necromancerman]

I checked this morning they're actually white border