contamination chromatic lantern

[particle]

was playing edh and this happend. i had {contamination} and one of my opponents had a {chromatic lantern}. should his lands be able to produce any color if his lantern came out after my contamination, or does timestamp not matter in this case?

[Mattao19]

was playing edh and this happend. i had {contamination} and one of my opponents gad a {chromatic lantern}. should his lands be able to produce any color if his lantern came out after my contamination, or does timestamp not matter in this case?

His lands all tap for {B} but he can still tap the lantern for any colour

[Kaleo42]

Yup. The replacement effect trumps any mana tapping of lands.

[Mattao19]

I beat Kaleo!!

[Kaleo42]

Sorry to dissapoint. I was on the phone with Nicki.

[Mattao19]

Lol

[Anoobass]

Who is "Nicki"

[Mlerner12]

Who is "Nicki"

Nicki Minaj?

[particle]

and same thing even if he had {celestial dawn} out? and if he donated me the {celestial dawn}?

[Kaleo42]

Who is "Nicki"

Fiancé


If your lands are plains contamination still says they tap for black and worse yet now you can only spend black as colorless mana.