Pithing needle

[Jeanies magic]

Would {pithing needle} stop {elixir of immortality}?

[DylanW18]

Yes

[gtfotis]

I believe your opponent can activate elixir of immortality in response to you playing pithing needle before it resolves though.

I'm probably wrong though 😰

[DylanW18]

Well, the point of {Pithing Needle} is that you play it first. If you play the needle after Elixir is already out, you're right gtfotis