Olivia and Mutavault

Started by MementoMori, July 26, 2013, 08:32:11 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

MementoMori

If you use {Olivia Voldaren} to steal an animated {Mutavault}, what happens when Mutavault stops being a Vampire?

I'm thinking you'll keep it, since control- changing effects are in a higher layer than type-changing effects, but I want to make sure.

Paraluke

Yes you will retain control...can't really find a rule to pin this but I believe both of us are right...

RESOLVED

Double-O-Scotch

"For as long as you control Olivia"

MementoMori

Yeah, I get that. I just wasn't sure if being a Vampire mattered other than making it a valid target. Like how {Runner's Bane} falls off if the enchanted creature's power goes above 3.

After a little Gatherer searching, I found {Cytoplast Manipulator}, which works similarly to Olivia but has some more useful rulings. So yeah, Olivia's controller would keep Mutavault until Olivia left the field.

Paraluke

The control change lasts as long as Cytoplast Manipulator is on the battlefield. It doesn't end if the creature loses all its +1/+1 counters, it stops being a creature, or if Cytoplast Manipulator becomes untapped.

Thanks for the tip, just pasted what  {Cytoplast Manipulator} says.