Judge

Started by Zman47, July 17, 2013, 03:17:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kaleo42

{Ætherling} gets +1/-1 from it's effect and the opponent casts a {turn//burn} using turn. What happens?

Similarly
You have {collective blessing}, {doran, the seige tower}, and you {giant growth} a {Tarmogoyf}, that is a 4/5 by it's own effect, after blocks have been declared. Your opponent casts turn on the goyf. How much damage will it asign.

rarehuntertay

Aetherling becomes 0/2
Tarmagoyf will assign 2 points

Kaleo42

Æther dies because it is a 0/1 with +1/-1.

Goyft assigns 7. Blessing gives the 0/1 goyf +3/+3 and so does giant growth making a total +6/+6 on a 0/1 making a 6/7 that assigns damage via toughness due to Doran.

This is because turn effects the base stats. The pumps are on a seperate layer.

Millionlittlee

Knew this go to random legacy thing that no one knows. Please

Zman47


Kaleo42

The path to being a judge starts with a firm grasp on the basic rules not the convoluted problems of cards that predate serious rules discusions.

Which are legal targets for a fuzed {far//away}?
{cartel aristocrat} with protection from blue
{kight of glory}
{knight of infamy}
A player with {witchbane orb}.

JustAWalrus

You can only retun either knight to it's owners hand

Kaleo42

Nope a fuzed {far//away} has a mana cost of {3}{U}{B}. While fuzed it is both a blue and a black spell meaning you can not target one of the knights because it is pro black.

Vampyvyrus

I wouldn't fuse it. I'd cast far by itself which can target any of the three creatures. The player having hex proof makes him unable to be targeted making away a useless spell.

Kaleo42

Read closer the cartel has protection from blue. Also what you would do is completely irrelevant to these questions.

Kaleo42

If you have a {clone} of a token copy of {Sprouting Phytohydra}, the origional hydra, and a {ravenger of the fells} in play, which cards will be destroyed by a X=0 {Gaze of granite}?

rarehuntertay

Ravager of the fells

Kaleo42

Very good. Unlike most tokens a copy token does have the origional's cmc.

Vampyvyrus

Cartel doesn't have protection from blue. It has the potential to have protection from blue. A sacrificed creature was never stated therefore she can be targeted.

But true it didn't answer your specific question.

Kaleo42

I specified that it did have blue in this question.