Trades

[Nissassagame]

People have a right to know the truth and I have a right to defend against lies. I can't apologize for my comments and I'm certain that many members agree.

[Dudecore]

Mods can't check your inbox, nor would we. Handle this like adults. Trade at your own risk and do not trade what you cannot afford to lose. /end

[InfinitiveDivinity]

And now that I've read comments a little further, I want to clarify again.

The cards I sent were Foundries. Highly sought after cards with almost triple the value he mentioned in this thread. Thrun was part of a bulk deal. He lied about sending me the cards and I was NOT given the option to keep the deal as is. It was a" take it or leave it" term given to me. As a matter of fact, I'm so disgusted, keep the Foundries as a gift Infinitive. It's one thing to have poor class and not be a man of your word and it's another to flat out lie. If anyone doubts the truth of what I'm saying, I'll gladly quote everything that was said to me. Maybe the Mods can read my inbox?

I never said I sent you the cards, and I never said that I gave you the option to keep the deal as it was. I asked if you would reconsider our trade, or if you would like for me to send back the lands. I think your misreading the comments

Dude, I quoted you word for word! Please mods check my inbox! OMG. This is fantastic!

If you're referring to the fact that I did not send out when I said I would, the yes, you're right on that part, but never did I say that you could have the option of keeping the deal as it originally was. Which is why Nyghthawk was saying that regardless, a gentlemens agreement should be upheld, and that I should have gave you that option.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

All I'm saying is that I don't see what lies you are saying I commited, other than the fact that I did not send out my end when I said I would, which I already told you had happened

[Stoneco1d869]

I had a similar situation with  {Boros Reckoner}s when they shot up. I ended up letting the guy off for the deal but only because I thought he wouldn't mail them and because he threw in a few freebies.

But once cards are mailed, or you "say" they are mailed then they are as good as traded. Ask yourself this. If you were dealing with a new trader who agreed to send first and did, would you alter the deal before sending out your end if prices change??

[Nissassagame]

I'll say no more on the issue. Resolved.

[Dudecore]

You've both been members long enough, I recommend you hash it out privately. No reason this has to work out poorly for either of you.

[Spikepit]

Seconding Dudecore. It is far beyond any control we as Mods have now and also not anyone's else's business.

[Barzini]

Wow i came into this thread thinking i could learn something about trading on imtg and came away thinking maybe its not such a great idea.

I hope the best of luck to you both.

[NyghtHawk]

Wow i came into this thread thinking i could learn something about trading on imtg and came away thinking maybe its not such a great idea.

I hope the best of luck to you both.

There are many successful trades every day here.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

I'm curious, can you have tracked mail returned to you if you request it?

[NyghtHawk]

I'm curious, can you have tracked mail returned to you if you request it?

EDIT:

You can, but only domestic it appears.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

I'm curious, can you have tracked mail returned to you if you request it?

You cannot.

Well now that is very interesting.

Nissa sent this to me about an hour ago:

By the way, because I was fearful that you would not send my Foundries back and I may be in the middle of some scam, I contacted Canada Post to return my item to sender as its tracking status was still "in transit". Last location was waiting for clearance at customs. So, i'll now have to resend them, at my expense, which is also unfair.

[InfinitiveDivinity]

I don't think his end was even sent either, I've asked for a tracking number to confirm this. If it is indeed true, then I'll drop this once and for all, I just want to make sure that he even sent his

[NyghtHawk]

I dont know how the Canadian post works.

You can intercept mail with USPS. Just found that out. But only for domestic shipping. If Canada is the same and it was still in Canada, I guess he could do it. You could ask him for the tracking number to see yourself what is going on with the package.

If either of you send and you feel the need, get tracking numbers so you both can see where everything is.