Sword and Planeswalker

[Antirayman]

I control a planeswalker and my opponent attacks the planeswalker with a creature equiped with Sword of Feast and Famine.
The sword dosen't trigger, right?

[Quisequise]

I control a planeswalker and my opponent attacks the planeswalker with a creature equiped with sword of feast and famine
The sword dosen't trigger, right?

{Sword of Feast and Famine}

[Quisequise]

No, since he damaging the Plainswalker, let's say  {Chandra, the Firebrand} for example, and not doing any damage to you, your opponent won't recieve the swords effect.

[Greg54js]

damaging a PW is not the same as damaging a player even though technically a PW is a player. so any effects saying when "x" deals combat damage to a player do "y" don't trigger

[NexisPrime]

I can only see this being true for combat damage. Because a judge ruled in favor of me when I used  {Rakdos's Return} and redirected the damage to his PW but he still had to discard the cards.

[Greg54js]

I can only see this being true for combat damage. Because a judge ruled in favor of me when I used  {Rakdos's Return} and redirected the damage to his PW but he still had to discard the cards.

what level was the judge?

[Double-O-Scotch]

Jk