Grave Betrayal

Started by Draem1, January 15, 2013, 08:35:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Draem1

If a creature is exiled does that constitute dying?  And if so does the exiled creature return under grave betrayal before it is exiled?

Gorzo

Dying means "goes to the graveyard from the battlefield." A card getting exiled never goes to the graveyard, so no, it does not count as dying.

RESOLVED

Teysa karlov

Cards that are exiled don't die they just get removed from play,

If a creature dies it is sent to the graveyard
( even if I doesnt make it there as in  {Rest in Peace})
being sacrificed, being killed my damage or having its toughness reduced to 0, the only ways to die, for a creature.

scarsabrex

Quote from: Shadowclothes on January 15, 2013, 08:44:14 PM
Cards that are exiled don't die they just get removed from play,

If a creature dies it is sent to the graveyard
( even if I doesnt make it there as in  {Rest in Peace})
being sacrificed, being killed my damage or having its toughness reduced to 0, the only ways to die, for a creature.

Well considering only creatures die... Yeah. Also they can die to the legendary rule, and the planes walker rule.

Jroch314


MTG Rebel

Quote from: scarsabrex on January 15, 2013, 09:16:31 PM
Quote from: Shadowclothes on January 15, 2013, 08:44:14 PM
Cards that are exiled don't die they just get removed from play,

If a creature dies it is sent to the graveyard
( even if I doesnt make it there as in  {Rest in Peace})
being sacrificed, being killed my damage or having its toughness reduced to 0, the only ways to die, for a creature.

Well considering only creatures die... Yeah. Also they can die to the legendary rule, and the planes walker rule.

I always thought those rules were funny.

Jace: "omg you have the same name as me" -kills himself-

Saint traft: "omg you have the same name as me" -kills himself-

Lol I do understand why they have the rule but at the same time its kinda funny lol