Main Menu

Redirect

Started by jhirt57, November 06, 2012, 10:51:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

jhirt57

Can u redirect rakdos returns or slaughter games since they say target opponent back to them? Thanks

Imdowd80

Quote from: jhirt57 on November 06, 2012, 10:51:47 PM
Can u {redirect} {rakdos returns} or {slaughter games} since they say target opponent back to them? Thanks
Rakdos you can, I'm not sure about slaughter games. Redirect isn't a "counter" so I don't know.

Maximo


Jroch314

Would you be able to name a new card? Or does the original chosen card stay the same?

Coffee Vampire

#4
When you copy a spell, you do everything in the rules text. So yeah you would.

Btw looked in rulings. Apparently you could not pick a new option for a charm.

Jroch314

Redirect doesn't copy. Just changes the target.

jhirt57

So even though slaughter games and rakdos return say target opponent you can redirect them back to them even though they wouldn't be an opponent and thus an invalid target?

Fenster

Cant redirect an "opponent" spell to its original caster.

Jroch314

So . . . Choose a new card for a {redirect}ed {slaughter games}? I'm thinking no . . .

Gorzo

Quote from: Jroch314 on November 07, 2012, 03:11:04 PM
So . . . Choose a new card for a {redirect}ed {slaughter games}? I'm thinking no . . .

Afraid not. Targets and elements (like the named card) are chosen when it goes on the stack. While you can redirect the target player, the named card is still already determined and isn't a "target" to be changed by the redirect.

Jroch314

Right that's what I thought.