Cabal therapy / tide hallow sculler

[peepew]

Ok so say I play my {tidehollow sculler} and I remove a sorcery/ instant/ creature (anything) from there hand and then I have my {cabal therapy} in my graveyard and I sac the sculler to pay the flashback cost and name the card removed by the sculler.

How will that resolve ? can I name the card and it will go back to there hand because the scullers gone but will it do that before so I can have it removed from there hand via therapy ?

[ChrisRodriguez]

{Cabal therapy} will resolve before the card goes back in the players hand form {tide hallow}. Once therapy resolves the is placed back in the players hand

[peepew]

[Kaleo42]

Wrong, classic cost vs resolve mistake.

As part of the cost, sculler is sacked and a target is named (in this case no "target" is needed, simply a statement of what card).

That is now on the stack. Before it can resolve state based is checked and finds a spell or ability was triggered. Sculler's return card is put on the stack.

State based finds nothing to attend to.

Sculler resolves putting the card back

Your spell resolves and checks their hand for the card. Finds it, and removes it.

[Fenster]

Wrong, classic cost vs resolve mistake.

As part of the cost, sculler is sacked and a target is named (in this case no "target" is needed, simply a statement of what card).

That is now on the stack. Before it can resolve state based is checked and finds a spell or ability was triggered. Sculler's return card is put on the stack.

State based finds nothing to attend to.

Sculler resolves putting the card back

Your spell resolves and checks their hand for the card. Finds it, and removes it.

Glaive'd!
Or was it gavel'd?

[BlackJester]

⛔🔨⏰

[Willthomjr]

Stop? Hammer time?

[peepew]

So then can I do it ?

[BlackJester]

So then can I do it ?

Yes.

[peepew]

YESSSS!!! 😀