Magus of the disk

Started by Purescum, September 06, 2012, 09:45:53 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Purescum

I had been playing with my friend whom knows far more about magic than me, as I was about to play magus of the disk ability (1 + tap creature: destroy all artifacts, enchantments, and creatures) he said that I couldn't use the ability because there were no artifacts in play. He said to use the ability I would have to have all of those things in play because it says "and" not "or." is this true or is he pulling a fast one on me? Thanks

P.s. this is my first post on here so if I missed the answer to my question somewhere I do apologize ahead of time, I could not find my answer online or in the rules

Ghebert

Quote from: Purescum on September 06, 2012, 09:45:53 AM
I had been playing with my friend whom knows far more about magic than me, as I was about to play {magus of the disk} ability (1 + tap creature: destroy all artifacts, enchantments, and creatures) he said that I couldn't use the ability because there were no artifacts in play. He said to use the ability I would have to have all of those things in play because it says "and" not "or." is this true or is he pulling a fast one on me? Thanks

P.s. this is my first post on here so if I missed the answer to my question somewhere I do apologize ahead of time, I could not find my answer online or in the rules

Ghebert

Yes your friend is wrong. This ability doesn't target. If it said "destroy target artifact" Then there would have to be one in play. This states ALL. So if there are no artifacts in play then the state will check for all three of these types of cards and if ANY are on the battlefield it will destroy them.

However if it said "Destroy target artifact, enchantment or creature" then you pick which to destroy.

Purescum

Thank you for clearing that up

Ghebert

No worries! This is what this part of the forums are for! Ask anytime!

Cindjor

Isn't there also a green card that says "destroy one of each permanent" in more words than that but it's the same principle. The "all" clause is a board wipe. Doesn't matter if you're only trying to kill 5 enchantments and no creatures are out, the ability still resolves.

Btw, tell your friend to play right ;)