Niv-mizzet or Nicol Bolas

Started by 15bm, September 03, 2012, 05:39:57 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

#noided

Quote from: KangaRod on September 03, 2012, 11:31:47 PM
I would say awareness is a rather large part of intelligence. When was the last time you saw an ignorant scientist?

Watch any national news network. You will find them there on a daily basis.

AgrusKos

Quote from: smokin terry on September 03, 2012, 11:30:35 PM
Quote from: BlackJester on September 03, 2012, 11:23:46 PM
(by the way, I'm really digging this topic) 👍

I would love it if Niv was the first character we see actually go from creature to PW. I know Bolas did this, but was more that he was always a PW, but they didn't have the "technology" to make him one at the time. To see Niv as a creature, then get his spark and show up as a PW in Gatecrash or "Sinker" would be great!
That would be really cool.
And was did venser have his spark when he was first printed as a creature?
Probs, but PW's hadn't come out yet.

ChrisRodriguez

Maybe this will help with the argument.
http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Multiverse/planeswalkers.aspx?x=mtg/multiverse/planeswalkers/nicolbolas
As far as jace and niv being friends; I dont think they are. According to the RtR trailer that's on one of the Pax videos wizards posted jace is out to stop niv from whatever niv is trying to do.

AgrusKos

Quote from: KangaRod on September 03, 2012, 11:36:59 PM
So, couldn't jace just teach him to planeswalk? I thought tibalt was taught by devils?
No, Tibbles infused himself with the devils, took a lot of pain, and when he did that his spark ignited. The devils didn't actually teach him

BlackJester

Quote from: Gummuh on September 03, 2012, 11:33:42 PM
Quote from: KangaRod on September 03, 2012, 11:31:47 PM
I would say awareness is a rather large part of intelligence. When was the last time you saw an ignorant scientist?

Watch any national news network. You will find them there on a daily basis.
This.

It defuses my argument a bit, but not all scientist are wise in many areas. You have watch their credentials.

Xanzurth

Quote from: BlackJester on September 03, 2012, 11:23:46 PM
(by the way, I'm really digging this topic) 👍

I would love it if Niv was the first character we see actually go from creature to PW. I know Bolas did this, but was more that he was always a PW, but they didn't have the "technology" to make him one at the time. To see Niv as a creature, then get his spark and show up as a PW in Gatecrash or "Sinker" would be great!

Venser was the first creature after Nicol bolas to gain the spark, and don't forget Karn.

Langku

I teach primary grade students and I've met 1st graders smarter, relatively, for their age than many adults. I'd say Niv is chronologically a child compared to Nicol but has shown a greater proclivity for learning. So relatively speaking: Niv not Nic.

Ace

Quote from: Langku on September 04, 2012, 01:42:41 AM
I teach primary grade students and I've met 1st graders smarter, relatively, for their age than many adults. I'd say Niv is chronologically a child compared to Nicol but has shown a greater proclivity for learning. So relatively speaking: Niv not Nic.

Very well put.

Fenster

Intelligence wise perhaps Niv has the highest iq. Perhaps...
Knowledge wise Nicol Bolas is still the undefeated champion. A being of such a long life and the ability to retain all information most definitly has the most vast knowledge pool.

DevilGin

Quote from: BlackJester on September 03, 2012, 11:30:58 PM
Was it Conflux?  Or was that just the mending of the Shards of Alara?  I thought it had to do with Karn giving up his spark to mend the rifts in Timespiral block or something.

I'm not up on my lore here. 😓

It was called 'the mending' that fixed the multiverse :)

And in terms of actually intelligence of raw thinking power I defiantely think niv has it. I mean he probably knows how to planeswalk without being one. Don't forget that izzet mages can manipulate time also.

DirtyMustachio

Well jace doesn't tend to like dragons all to much does he lol.

BlackJester

I remembered Karn and Venser after I hit Post. ::)  But we had them as creatures, then we don't see them for a LOOOOOOONG time, and then we get them as PWs. I still Think it would be cool to have a character transform in front of us, so to speak.

The Mending!  Right!  I'll say Bolas might have been more intelligent pre-mending, but post-mending it's Niv.

smokin terry

Quote from: BlackJester on September 04, 2012, 10:52:42 AM
I remembered Karn and Venser after I hit Post. ::)  But we had them as creatures, then we don't see them for a LOOOOOOONG time, and then we get them as PWs. I still Think it would be cool to have a character transform in front of us, so to speak.

The Mending!  Right!  I'll say Bolas might have been more intelligent pre-mending, but post-mending it's Niv.
It would be really cool to see niv gain a spark.

Xanzurth

Quote from: smokin terry on September 04, 2012, 11:17:06 AM
Quote from: BlackJester on September 04, 2012, 10:52:42 AM
I remembered Karn and Venser after I hit Post. ::)  But we had them as creatures, then we don't see them for a LOOOOOOONG time, and then we get them as PWs. I still Think it would be cool to have a character transform in front of us, so to speak.

The Mending!  Right!  I'll say Bolas might have been more intelligent pre-mending, but post-mending it's Niv.
It would be really cool to see niv gain a spark.

If Niv gained the spark or Planeswalk if he already has it would bring him to the attention of Bolas, which would be a bad thing. I do believe Niv knows this, therefore stays on Ravnica and amassing knowledge       

scarsabrex

Quote from: AgrusKos on September 03, 2012, 11:26:36 PM
Quote from: BlackJester on September 03, 2012, 11:23:05 PM
Didn't Bolas lose much of his knowledge/power after the rift-healing (or whatever it was called)?
The Conflux. Helped Jester!!!

wrong it was the mending

which basically depowered planeswalkers to not god levels.