Butt Bumps 68 cards, 0 sideboard 1 {Doran, the Siege Tower} Commander 1 {Disowned Ancestor} 1 {Treefolk Harbinger} 1 {Nyx-Fleece Ram} 1 {Wall of Omens} 1 {Gyre Sage} 1 {Primal Druid} 1 {Skinshifter} 1 {Sylvan Caryatid} 1 {Wall of Blossoms} 1 {Bosk Banneret} 1 {Grizzled Leotau} 1 {Korozda Guildmage} 1 {Black Poplar Shaman} 1 {Abzan Beastmaster} 1 {Carven Caryatid} 1 {Scourge of Skola Vale} 1 {Indomitable Ancients} 1 {Erebos, God of the Dead} 1 {Tree of Perdition} 1 {Nylea, God of the Hunt} 1 {Ondu Giant} 1 {Tree of Redemption} 1 {Dauntless Dourbark} 1 {Leaf-Crowned Elder} 1 {Lumberknot} 1 {Unstoppable Ash} 1 {Ancient Spider} 1 {Trostani, Selesnya's Voice} 1 {Silklash Spider} 1 {Magnigoth Treefolk} 1 {Seedguide Ash} 1 {Timber Protector} 1 {Karametra, God of Harvests} 1 {Old Ghastbark} 1 {Sapling of Colfenor} 1 {Oathsworn Giant} 1 {Pontiff of Blight} 1 {Ulvenwald Hydra} 1 {Deadwood Treefolk} 1 {Ulvenwald Observer} 1 {Dragonlord Dromoka} 1 {Engulfing Slagwurm} 1 {Ghoultree} 43 creatures 1 {Slagwurm Armor} 1 {Sol Ring} 1 {Darksteel Mutation} 1 {Valorous Stance} 1 {Assault Formation} 1 {Rampant Growth} 1 {Sheltering Word} 1 {Tower Defense} 1 {Behind the Scenes} 1 {Sudden Spoiling} 1 {Map the Wastes} 1 {Putrefy} 1 {Shield of the Oversoul} 1 {Foul Renewal} 1 {Explosive Vegetation} 1 {Momentous Fall} 1 {Mwonvuli Acid-Moss} 1 {Ob Nixilis Reignited} 1 {Sight of the Scalelords} 1 {Ajani, Mentor of Heroes} 1 {Vraska the Unseen} 1 {Elspeth, Sun's Champion} 1 {Sorin, Grim Nemesis} 1 {Garruk, Apex Predator} 24 other spells |
Quote from: Respawned2 on September 28, 2016, 08:04:46 AM
Hey all... First, I want to say I am relatively new to the commander format. That being said, this is a new commander deck I've been Working on but I need to trim down a few more cards before I add lands. Any and all help appreciated! :)
Quote from: JordanCirk on September 29, 2016, 03:30:25 PM
Welcome to the wonderful world of Commander!
Some cards I noticed are weak within the deck are:
-Primal Druid: Being able to only do the ability whenever it dies just makes it worse than {Sakura-Tribe Elder}. Also without a sac outlet I wouldn't even consider it.
-Old Ghastbark: You have bigger, cheaper creatures than this one.
-Sheltering Word: This card is too situational. And if you wanted to run something like this effect, I'd prefer {Vines of Vastwood}.
-Map the Wastes: In my personal opinion, not that great for a ramp card. Would much rather run {Cultivate} or {Skyshroud Claim}.
Otherwise the deck looks good! Lmk if you need any more advice, I'd love to help.
Quote from: Respawned2 on September 30, 2016, 03:57:32 AMTypically it's better (in my opinion at least) to get a bigger creature out faster rather than making a small creature a bit bigger. So stuff like {Kodama's Reach} and {Cultivate} are nice cause of this. Obviously modern infect would disagree with me, but for commander getting threats out is huge especially in a creature based deck like yours.Quote from: JordanCirk on September 29, 2016, 03:30:25 PM
Welcome to the wonderful world of Commander!
Some cards I noticed are weak within the deck are:
-Primal Druid: Being able to only do the ability whenever it dies just makes it worse than {Sakura-Tribe Elder}. Also without a sac outlet I wouldn't even consider it.
-Old Ghastbark: You have bigger, cheaper creatures than this one.
-Sheltering Word: This card is too situational. And if you wanted to run something like this effect, I'd prefer {Vines of Vastwood}.
-Map the Wastes: In my personal opinion, not that great for a ramp card. Would much rather run {Cultivate} or {Skyshroud Claim}.
Otherwise the deck looks good! Lmk if you need any more advice, I'd love to help.
Thank you for the tips...i like primal druid in this deck cuz of its toughness. If I keep swinging with a 3/3 each and every turn, eventually he will die or I will win lol... Plus I have a few sac outlets thou not many
Old ghastbark was already on my cutting board... Think it's time to cut him
Sheltering word Gains life, you think pump is better? I mean I'll take your word on it since I'm new to the format... May just cut it all together as I still have a few to trim
I thought map the waste would be good due to the small boost to my weakest creature, but again, noob to commander so I'll prob go with one of your suggestions
Thanks for the input! :)
Quote from: Thefluffymacheen on September 30, 2016, 01:53:15 PM
Typically it's better (in my opinion at least) to get a bigger creature out faster rather than making a small creature a bit bigger. So stuff like {Kodama's Reach} and {Cultivate} are nice cause of this. Obviously modern infect would disagree with me, but for commander getting threats out is huge especially in a creature based deck like yours.