Guy 1 trades {Stormbreath Dragon} and {Elspeth, Sun's Champion}
For
Guy 2's 4 x {Thundermaw Hellkite}
Who comes off better?
(I did this trade and in hindsight I'm trying to see if I did good or not)
Guy 2, unless he needs the playset for another format
I'd say guy 1. Storm breath is IMO better than thundermaw, and will only go up for the next 2 years.
Looking at monetary value, Guy 2. Stormbreath+Elspeth is $64 and 4 Thundermaws is only $52.
Quote from: Thetrufflehunter on October 01, 2013, 11:38:50 PM
I'd say guy 1. Storm breath is IMO better than thundermaw, and will only go up for the next 2 years.
This probably didn't make sense. I thought this was post-trade. The person receiving the storm breath dragon got the better end IMO.
Quote from: Phoenix X30 on October 01, 2013, 11:36:24 PM
Guy 1 trades {Stormbreath Dragon} and {Elspeth, Sun's Champion}
For
Guy 2's 4 x {Thundermaw Hellkite}
Who comes off better?
(I did this trade and in hindsight I'm trying to see if I did good or not)
Are you guy 1 or guy 2?
1 I didn't need/want elspeth or SBD.
Bad move
Using straight up values you lost about $12 but if you value the cards you got higher (i.e. you'll actually use them) it was probably worth it.
Guy 1 wins by a lot.
Quote from: Wizardmook on October 04, 2013, 01:00:13 PM
$12 shortfall? I wouldn't worry about chump change, you got what you wanted for cards you're not interested in. I trade what I need, never look into long term investment and if I lose a couple of bucks so what. Enjoy the cards.
glad to hear what you do, but he asked who came out on top, in which case it is undebatably trader 2