Thedeck2012

Quote from: Karrthus on April 22, 2012, 11:56:26 PM

I honestly don't see this deck winning that much. All I see are all the most expensive cards in the game thrown together with no real purpose.

Well based only on game 1. What decks do you think I have trouble beating? Because I can't think of any.

Speed red, what are you gonna do against an old school Mog Fanatic deck. Really

Quote from: Lachrymology on April 23, 2012, 11:32:15 PM

Quote from: Karrthus on April 22, 2012, 11:56:26 PM

I honestly don't see this deck winning that much. All I see are all the most expensive cards in the game thrown together with no real purpose.

Well based only on game 1. What decks do you think I have trouble beating? Because I can't think of any.

Speed red, what are you gonna do against an old school Mog Fanatic deck. Really

Watch them stall and lose game one. Game 2 sb and win. 2-0. Sligh in vintage is, IMO, not a good idea. I will edit and post a SB if necessary but like i said it would be very meta dependent on what I'm  running. I've played in many shops that have vintage tourneys that have no players with any power at all, maybe FoW and duals at best. My board in that environment would be intensely color and aggro hated. In a prxied tournament maybe a standard board can be comprised. In a legit type 1 tournament, I would have to see the actual players, assume I know what they are going to run and then board forum them and my two worst matchups possible in vintage. Which really aren't any but mirror matches.

And what's Mott fanatic going to do to me? Kill my one gorilla shaman so I cant blow up the moxen he likely doesn't have in a mono red deck? Lighting bolt me a few times and have no cards in hand? Sac two mountains and get his fireblast mana drained? What if inside in chalice of the void for 1? Or chill? Propaganda? Blue elemental blast? All regular hatred for r/gbeats. I just don't see sligh getting it done. If you have apprentIce and want to run some games let me know. I'd be more than eager to see how keeper would fair against sligh/goblins/something like that.

IMO, this deck is junk. Other than price of course. Don't get bent out of shape about it. Not everyone is going to like your deck list. Honestly I don't blame you though. If I had those cards I would do it to, but differently. Lol

If you really do have all those cards I'd like to see your take on a turn 1 win with a Raging Goblin. Without those cards the best you can get is turn 2. Unless you top deck 2 Lotus Petals.

IMO, this deck is junk. Other than price of course. Don't get bent out of shape about it. Not everyone is going to like your deck list. Honestly I don't blame you though. If I had those cards I would do it to, but differently. Lol

I'm not bent about it, it's just that I consider my knowledge of the vintage format generally superior to most mtg players, vintage savee or not. Idk your experience, so not to discredit you but - any "vintage" players know this deck and know its far from junk. It's probably the most consistent build in the format well over 10 years.  Keeper and it's variants have existed forever. And idk about turn ones with raging goblin. Although if it's goblins u want I can show you a neat little trick with food chain to turn one someone.

I don't get to play much vintage. Everyone here is obsessed with standard. It's rare I can find some one to play this format with. Oh, turn 1 Raging Goblin. Play mountain, Black Lotus, mountain for goblin, lotus for Dark Ritual and cast Hatred. Lol. I have deck with this combo minus the lotus. I have to use other cards and go turn 2 with it.

Btw, plz post on the food chain. You have my attention.

Btw, plz post on the food chain. You have my attention.

I'll try to get a decklist up later.