Imink

User accused: Lmink

Reason: in the "Birdbrain's Art Contest" he made new accounts just to add votes so he could win the contest. This violates the "Do Not Lie" tenet of iMtG law.

Evidence:

Voting log for the poll in question. Every single but one vote for Imink's is by 0 posts user.

id_member   real_name   label
12068   Imink   Imink's
12691   Cuzzig   Imink's
12694   CallmeCRASH   Imink's
12705   Turtel   Imink's
12714   Dealhome   Imink's
12754   Imtheelephant   Imink's
12798   (.Y.)   Imink's
12857   Fluxcap1   Imink's
12883   jAzz   Imink's

Victims:
Myself. Infinitive Divinity (who should have first place) and anyone else who participated in the art contest.

Thoughts? As a victim and with this substantial evidence by Piotr, I feel that he is certainly guilty.

Wow...just...wow.

And he wasn't exactly sneaky about it with the name choices, lol. That's awful!

And he wasn't exactly sneaky about it with the name choices, lol. That's awful!

For sure! He has a chance to defend himself of course.

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

If it is decided that Lmink is guilty, yes. He will get first, I second, and birdbrain will have to do a rerun for third.

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

the contest? Yes, infinitedivinity won. And I think I'll throw in extra prizes as well for the winners. I think we also need a way to make contests safer. So what are we going to do about this?

Quote from: Mlerner12 on July 31, 2013, 09:37:38 PM

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

the contest? Yes, infinitedivinity won. And I think I'll throw in extra prizes as well for the winners. I think we also need a way to make contests safer. So what are we going to do about this?

Well, Piotr has proven that he can monitor who votes for who. I don't see another way to cheat in this kind of thing outside out what we've just probably caught Lmink doing.

From a mod perspective, I know I will be monitoring these contests done by this kind of voting much more closely.

Time for a dislike.

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

Hold on, I gotta load up on popcorn and soda.

I actually disliked because of a differing reason.

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

Precisely. Let's ease up on the assumptions and give the man a chance to defend himself. You all would like the same thing if accused, so let's afford him the opportunity.

I actually disliked because of a differing reason.

I not judging you Mlerner, I just know people like Slenderbro hit somewhere around -30 karma during a trial.

Wow...