Wanna fight?!

Started by Brandalog, July 25, 2012, 04:26:04 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Brandalog

{stuffy doll} + {precursor golem} + {blood feud}

scarsabrex

nonbo. golem only copies if the spell targets a golem and a golem only.

#noided

Quote from: scarsabrex on July 25, 2012, 04:48:09 PM
nonbo. golem only copies if the spell targets a golem and a golem only.

No, it works. The spell must only target one golem. Multiple targets is fine, just only one can be a golem.

scarsabrex

targets ONLY a single golem. different from a spell that targets a single golem and other targets.

AgrusKos


scarsabrex

sigh. the wording for precursor is it'll copy spells that target ONLY a single golem. if you target a single golem and stuffy doll that is not ONLY a single golem.

Brandalog

Fairly sure your incorrect scars.

scarsabrex

a dog and a cat is more than ONLY a single dog.

#noided

Where's BJ when you need him :/

KulrathKnight

Quote from: Brandalog on July 25, 2012, 07:38:07 PM
Fairly sure your incorrect scars.

Scars is right. A ruling for {Precursor Golem} states: "If an instant or sorcery spell has multiple targets, but it's targeting the same Golem with all of them (such as {Agony Warp} targeting the same Golem twice), Precursor Golem's last ability will trigger."

That single golem needs to be either the only target or every target for Precursor's ability to trigger.

Brandalog

Quote from: KulrathKnight on July 25, 2012, 07:53:08 PM
Quote from: Brandalog on July 25, 2012, 07:38:07 PM
Fairly sure your incorrect scars.

Scars is right. A ruling for {Precursor Golem} states: "If an instant or sorcery spell has multiple targets, but it's targeting the same Golem with all of them (such as {Agony Warp} targeting the same Golem twice), Precursor Golem's last ability will trigger."

That single golem needs to be either the only target or every target for Precursor's ability to trigger.

His last ability meaning it'll copy the instant or sorcery will trigger. That's what I'm trying to say. That's what that ruling states.

scarsabrex

if you are targeting anything more than one golem be it a 2nd golem or an "it" precursor will not trigger.

Brandalog

Can you find me a ruling please. 

scarsabrex

kulrath pointed out the exact ruling. I am pointing out the effect text. if you can rationalize that a spell targeting stuffy doll and a golem is targeting ONLY a single golem which, precursor stipulates for its trigger rationalize it for us.

Brandalog

My bad I misunderstood what the ruling stated.