Kalitas vs indestructible

Started by Lunis22, January 27, 2016, 08:13:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Lunis22

I have noticed that the new set has some new ways of dealing with indestructible. After reading the effect of kalitas, I am confused as to whether his effect is yet another way of doing this. [If a non token creature would die exile it instead.] this to me says that it would work to exile cards that would usually immune to a cards destroy effects due to indestructible. This belief is derived from the fact that other cards that deal with effects of when a card dies does not specify [would die], just simply when this or another creature dies, this action happens. Any thoughts or rulings about this case that I have missed?

Kaylesh

First off, while it is a question about a standard card, this would probably fit best in "rules".

To answer your question, let's take a look at what happens:

702.12b: A permanent with indestructible can't be destroyed. Such permanents aren't destroyed by lethal damage, and they ignore the state-based action that checks for lethal damage (see rule 704.5g).

{kalitas, traitor of geth}.

LinkCelestrial

In irther words, because it's indestructible it wouldn't die so it isn't exiled.

Thefluffymacheen

Quote from: LinkCelestrial on January 27, 2016, 01:52:46 PM
In irther words, because it's indestructible it wouldn't die so it isn't exiled.
But it can still be killed with sacrifice and -1/-1 counters, in which case Kalitas (or Kletis as my local card shop calls him) would exile the indestructible creature.

Kaylesh

Quote from: Thefluffymacheen on January 27, 2016, 03:41:55 PM
Quote from: LinkCelestrial on January 27, 2016, 01:52:46 PM
In irther words, because it's indestructible it wouldn't die so it isn't exiled.
But it can still be killed with sacrifice and -1/-1 counters, in which case Kalitas (or Kletis as my local card shop calls him) would exile the indestructible creature.
True. It doesn't add a new way to get rid of it, though.

As an aside, my apologies for my half answer.

griffin131

Quote from: Lunis22 on January 27, 2016, 08:13:09 AM
I have noticed that the new set has some new ways of dealing with indestructible. After reading the effect of kalitas, I am confused as to whether his effect is yet another way of doing this. [If a non token creature would die exile it instead.] this to me says that it would work to exile cards that would usually immune to a cards destroy effects due to indestructible. This belief is derived from the fact that other cards that deal with effects of when a card dies does not specify [would die], just simply when this or another creature dies, this action happens. Any thoughts or rulings about this case that I have missed?
To explain the difference, "would die" means that Kalitas' ability is a replacement effect - so the card never hits the graveyard, and the replacement can't be responded to. Importantly, "dies" triggers don't happen.
"Whenever a creature dies" means it's a trigger, so it uses the stack and can be responded to normally. Other "dies" effects can also trigger.