Format Idea

[LinkCelestrial]

modern started with the modern border. What about a new format with the M15 border? Thoughts? Include supplement products?

[Rass]

Supplemental products would break it.

[Mr_Fahrenheit]

Thats basically standard with the power level of sets these days, plus the old extended was superfluous to the needs of wizards and players alike.

[LinkCelestrial]

Supplemental products would break it.

Only really MM2. No? I like the idea of cards originally printed in new borders in supplement sets.

We can also make a ban list.

[LinkCelestrial]

When the premiered the new boarder I suggested that old boards were Alpha-7th
New boarders are 8-M14
And new are M15- current

I thought about suggesting formats such as pre-modern (no new boarders)
Neo-modern (only newest boarders)

Definitions sound good to me. Pre-modern as in alpha-7th? Could be fun if the power 9 and some other offenders are banned.

[MuggyWuggy]

i mean its slowed down a ton since they started the new border.

[Rass]

Supplemental products would break it.

Only really MM2. No? I like the idea of cards originally printed in new borders in supplement sets.

We can also make a ban list.

I'm thinking commander and duel decks would break it.

[LinkCelestrial]

Supplemental products would break it.

Only really MM2. No? I like the idea of cards originally printed in new borders in supplement sets.

We can also make a ban list.

I'm thinking commander and duel decks would break it.

I don't really think so.

[Rass]

Supplemental products would break it.

Only really MM2. No? I like the idea of cards originally printed in new borders in supplement sets.

We can also make a ban list.

I'm thinking commander and duel decks would break it.

I don't really think so.

Certain colors will get advantages because duel decks don't share all five colors. Also as post above. Or even  {Sol Ring} is too powerful.

[LinkCelestrial]

{True-Name Nemisis} isn't in the M15 border...

[Rass]

{True-Name Nemisis} isn't in the M15 border...

Yes but they can print something in the future that is similar.

[Rass]

{true-name nemesis}

{golgari charm}

I sort of kid....

Charm is not legal in this format.

[Kaylesh]

{true-name nemesis}

{golgari charm}

I sort of kid....

Charm is not legal in this format.

WELL NEITHER IS TRUE NAME!

If you include supplemental products. FTV products would be too... I think the new formats would struggle with the power in those..

[LinkCelestrial]

{true-name nemesis}

{golgari charm}

I sort of kid....

Charm is not legal in this format.

WELL NEITHER IS TRUE NAME!

If you include supplemental products. FTV products would be too... I think the new formats would struggle with the power in those..

Would it be too much work to ban the offenders?

[Kaylesh]

{true-name nemesis}

{golgari charm}

I sort of kid....

Charm is not legal in this format.

WELL NEITHER IS TRUE NAME!

If you include supplemental products. FTV products would be too... I think the new formats would struggle with the power in those..

Would it be too much work to ban the offenders?

It's less work to not include supplements. I get your point however.