Thoughtsieze or Surgical Extraction

[Teysa karlov]

Play both!!!! Thoughtsieze their win con then extract every copy they have

[Brawler_1337]

Thoughtseize, by far. Surgical Extraction can only hit cards you have already seen, and is dead turn 1. Thoughtseize can take out a threat you can't deal with, can rip out counterspells to clear the way for your combo, gives you information about your opponent's possible lines of play, informs you of what your opponent is playing during game 1, takes out a card turn 1, and can make a 3/4 Goyf on turn 2 (fetch land, Thoughtseize, and another nonsorcery, nonland card).

[Skullguy725]

Why not both? Nothing better than T1 swamp into T Seize into Surgical

Goodbye {Tarmogoyf}
See you...never

[Destore117]

I don't understand why tarmogoyf is considered like a god card >.>
I mean he's clambering up to the {Storm Crow} cloud.

[Mattao19]

I don't understand why tarmogoyf is considered like a god card >.>
I mean he's clambering up to the {Storm Crow} cloud.

It's a $200 card for a reason trust he's a baws!!

[Dudecore]

Goyf is a way for fair decks to put a clock on. Its valuable in most formats the way {Force of Will} is in Legacy

[Destore117]

I van get force of will but what about goyf makes him the- RUN!!!

[Falcon182]

I van get force of will but what about goyf makes him the- RUN!!!

Turn 2 3/4 that grows into a 6/7 late game is pretty good. For CMC 2. I don't know why he's a $200 creature card but he's about as good as you can get for legacy creatures.

[Destore117]

Oh. Mana cost is 2. That makes a lot more sense. Especially with something like Thoughtsiezing an artifact land
(2/3 + your Thoughtsieze 3/4)