What are the most HATED cards?

Started by JordanCirk, April 23, 2014, 01:39:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

JordanCirk

I wanted to open this up because I want to know peoples opinions about which cards NO one should ever use in commander. The cards have to be ones that ruin the fun of the format, have a lot of "feel bads" afterwords, and just cards that in your opinion shouldn't be played.

Xaol

1. Land Destruction of any kind
2. {Iona, Shield of Emeria}
3. {Eye of the Storm}
4. {Nevermore} naming someone's commander
5. {Enter the Infinite} because it takes people forever to resolve it
6. Cards that give extra turns
7. {Back to Basics}, {Blood Moon}
8. {Stasis}
9. {Balance}
10. {Desertion}
11. {Jin-Gitaxias}
12. {Consecrated Sphinx}
13. {Rhystic Study}

Bear in mind that my list is subjective, it's based off of my experiences and I'm sure other people have tons to add. Hope this helps!

MisterJH

I agree with most of that except extra turns, idt 1 extra turn would make people too mad.. Infinite however? Well thats a different story

Xaol

Quote from: MisterJH on April 23, 2014, 03:05:55 PM
I agree with most of that except extra turns, idt 1 extra turn would make people too mad.. Infinite however? Well thats a different story
Depends on the player I guess. I have a friend who is already a slow player, when he casts {Time Stretch} and then copies it most of us just concede. not because he would beat us, but because him taking an extra four turns would take upwards of 20 minutes.

MisterJH


FustyDavorite

Also stuff like  {Sorin Markov} and  {Magister Sphinx}

FustyDavorite

Quote from: Xaol on April 23, 2014, 02:58:39 PM
1. Land Destruction of any kind
2. {Iona, Shield of Emeria}
3. {Eye of the Storm}
4. {Nevermore} naming someone's commander
5. {Enter the Infinite} because it takes people forever to resolve it
6. Cards that give extra turns
7. {Back to Basics}, {Blood Moon}
8. {Stasis}
9. {Balance}
10. {Desertion}
11. {Jin-Gitaxias}
12. {Consecrated Sphinx}
13. {Rhystic Study}


Bear in mind that my list is subjective, it's based off of my experiences and I'm sure other people have tons to add. Hope this helps!

Someone hates blue lol

DYMongoose


rarehuntertay

I love casting  {Enter the Infinite} with my deck. Means I win. Unless they have infinite life...

Sparkle Ninja

{Exclusion Ritual}
Is more annoying than {Nevermore} due to the fact that you exile the commander

Remillo

Quote from: Sparkle Ninja on April 23, 2014, 05:03:24 PM
{Exclusion Ritual}
Is more annoying than {Nevermore} due to the fact that you exile the commander

I'm gonna point you to words on Exclusion Ritual.  Because it specifies the exiled card, the card needs to be in exile for the ability to work.  If the commander is placed in the Command Zone, then it's not in Exile and Ritual ends up being a really overcosted exile effect.

Anyways, I'm fine with almost anything, as long as people have somewhat of  a sporting chance to win the game.  Mass Land Destruction is fine, as long as it isn't just used Willy-Nilly.  I'm fine with normal land destruction to take out problematic lands.  Extra turns are fine as long as they don't take forever.

MuggyWuggy

 {Vorinclex, Voice of Hunger}
{Hall of Gemstone}
{winter orb}

MuggyWuggy

Title it: deck most likely to be thrown in trash

Sparkle Ninja

Quote from: Muggywuggy on April 23, 2014, 06:19:03 PM
Title it: deck most likely to be thrown in trash
Some guy raged at my Animar deck and ripped an {Ornithopter} in half

MisterJH