Ban List Discussion (speculation)

Started by rarehuntertay, April 23, 2014, 08:03:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

rarehuntertay

So, we are about a week away from new Banned/Restricted list announcement. What would you like to see banned or unbanned? And keep it civil please!

cltrn81

If {tarmogoyf} or Bob get banned imagonna cry.  Doubt it....but if they do....😭

rarehuntertay

I would like to see  {Umezawa's Jitte} unbanned. It has never seen Modern play and I believe it could bring something to the format.

I would like to see something done about infinite combo but I currently cannot think of what... Lol

MisterJH

I think they should ban everything expensive for a week so ican has buying it
Then unban it once ive built my deck :)

DrainCleaner

Gotta ban island. Way too overpowered.

Zellius

 I personally wanna see blood braid elf unbanned now that they banned deathrites and see how the meta goes from there.

rarehuntertay

Quote from: Taysby on April 23, 2014, 09:35:52 AM
AGain?  They just did one...

My thoughts, {pestermite} {deceiver exarch} and {birthing pod}

They do one every three months, usually right before a new set comes out. Last I read, the new announcement will be made on April 28

MacheteMable

#7
They won't ban anything. Modern has become pretty diverse with no one deck completely dominating the field. I'd love to see {Umezawa's beststick} and {preordain} unbanned though.

DeathlyFoiend

Quote from: Taysby on April 23, 2014, 09:35:52 AM
AGain?  They just did one...

My thoughts, {pestermite} {deceiver exarch} and {birthing pod}
So kill decks that aren't dominating? Let's ruin the format!

DeathlyFoiend

Quote from: MacheteMable on April 23, 2014, 09:59:57 AM
They won't ban anything. Modern has become pretty diverse with no one deck completely dominating the field. I'd love to see {Umezawa's beststick} and {preordain} unbanned though.
Umezawa's would kill many tier 1.5 decks, and fringe others. I would like A few cards changed up on the banlist. I'll post a list I have together soon enough.

DrainCleaner

BRING BACK EGGS! MWAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

InfinitiveDivinity

My friends and I had a pretty good discussion on this topic the other day, the main thing we decided on was that they should unban {Green Sun's Zenith} and ban {Birthing Pod}.

rarehuntertay

To me, Pod isn't the issue. I can deal with pod. What is harder to deal with is  {Pestermite},  {Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker}, or  {Splinter Twin}

DeathlyFoiend

Quote from: InfinitiveDivinity on April 23, 2014, 10:22:42 AM
My friends and I had a pretty good discussion on this topic the other day, the main thing we decided on was that they should unban {Green Sun's Zenith} and ban {Birthing Pod}.
That still kills both Kiki and Melira pod while also lowering their toolbox. Birthing Pod isn't even dominating, so i don't see why you guys keep thinking that Pod should take a hot.

cltrn81

Pod is cool and it really shakes up the meta IMO.  That way cards like {abrupt decay} and {inquisition of Kozilek} are not so powerful.  The fact Pod decks rely on higher CMC cards I think makes the entire meta more diverse.