Which is better?

Started by Spencer Addington, March 31, 2014, 10:02:29 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Spencer Addington

{proclamation of rebirth}, {immortal servitude}, {reveillark} or {sun titan}? This is for a boros soul sisters that I have. Here's the list:

Norin The OP

57 cards, 15 sideboard


2 {Ghost Quarter}
4 {Clifftop Retreat}
4 {Sacred Foundry}
4 {Battlefield Forge}
9 {Plains}

23 lands


2 {Hero of Bladehold}
3 {Ranger of Eos}
4 {Soul's Attendant}
4 {Soul Warden}
2 {Purphoros, God of the Forge}
4 {Champion of the Parish}
3 {Norin the Wary}
4 {Ajani's Pridemate}

26 creatures


4 {Lightning Helix}
4 {Path to Exile}

8 other spells


Sideboard

2 {Rest in Peace}
2 {Shatterstorm}
2 {Wear // Tear}
3 {Sowing Salt}
3 {Boros Charm}
3 {Leyline of Sanctity}

15 sideboard cards


MisterJH

I feel proclamation is most efficient for your deck asuming its like most soul sisters and focused a lot on some 1 drops

Sparkle Ninja


Silent1236

I kinda like proclamation due to CMC. 

MisterJH

Yea^ its just too good of a fit in this deck, the rest dont quite justify themselves
You dont have enough of any other CMC to justify anything besides sun titan, which is super expensive in whats essentially a nonaggressive weenie deck.. Maybe SB 1 titan if you must

cltrn81

#5
I think {sun titan} rounds out your mana curve given your low CC creatures.  I like his late game potential he brings to this deck....especially since reanimating removed creatures is more of a mid-late game tactic anyway.....IMO


I also like {ajani vengeant} in this deck but not too much in the theme I suppose

MisterJH

Its just a dead card until lateish game and he hardly has any non 1cmc cards

I think 1 sun titan would be alright but thats your call, i just dont think any more would be beneficial since reanimating your 1 drops is crucial

Spencer Addington

I'll add 1 sun titan and 2 proclaims toon of rebirth. If I don't like the sun titan I'll replace it with another rebirth.

MisterJH

I find that agreeable lol

InfinitiveDivinity

Ever consider {Immortal Servitude}? For 1 more mana you can just bring back your whole gy.

EDIT: Nvm, it's already listed as an option. Well that's my recommendation.

InfinitiveDivinity

On a side note, a singleton or even two {Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx} could be really good. Especially with those Leylines coming in, game 2 can get explosive.

rarehuntertay

I would go with servitude

MisterJH

Servitude is good and all but chances are hell just cast it for 4 mana and get 1 drops back anyways, so its a slightly worse card, hell likely never cast it for 5 cuz his 3 drop creature just isnt crucial, and if he casts it for 6.. Well he might as well get a sun titan out of it

cltrn81

IDK......I think reanimating is typically a 50/50 chance of being useful.  Meaning you either are stuck with a reanimation card that you don't need right now or you do need it and then it may still only be marginally effective.  With the Titan at least you have a beater that could make a big difference in a long game.

{divinity of pride} looks good in this too

Dstyle1

Servitude is a spell. It can be countered like a spell.

If you use proclamations forecast it's an ability, so it can't be countered. Only way to stop it us with a needle effect or counter an ability.