Spear of heliod vs extort

Started by Master Vorzwick, January 21, 2014, 02:52:18 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Master Vorzwick

So I have spear of heliod on board and I'm going against a deck that has creatures with extort. My opponent casts a creature spell and extorts me with another creature already on board. Can I activate the spear of heliod and destroy the creature that was used to extort me, or does it not work since extort says " looses life" and not "deals damage"?

DylanW18

#1
It does not work for 2(?) reasons


1.) Loss of life is not damage

2.) The creature was not what dealt the damage. If it said "this creature deals 1 damage to each opponent and you gain life equal to the life lost this way" it would work

RESOLVED

Master Vorzwick

Thanks. That cleared that up for me. :)