Heroic, Coordinated Assault

Started by CbStrad, September 19, 2013, 02:41:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

CbStrad

So, let's say I have an {Akroan Crusader} and throw a {Coordinated Assault} on him:

1) Could I target the same Crusader both times, and

2) If I can, would I get one token or two out of this?

Wally

Up to two. That's the key phrase. You have only chosen one, and you cannot choose the same one twice to fulfil up to two as it would still be a total of one.

One creature. One effect. One token.

Mattao19

Can you give the token the other +1/+0?

DylanW18

No, the spell resolves before the token is placed.

Gorzo

Quote from: Wally on September 19, 2013, 02:44:47 AM
One creature. One effect. One token.

Coming this Fall to a theatre near you...

RESOLVED
The Movie

Mattao19

Quote from: DylanW18 on September 19, 2013, 03:33:54 AM
No, the spell resolves before the token is placed.

Are you sure doesn't it target before it resolves? Then once it's targeted that's when Heroic resolves and places a token. Then the spell resolves.

Gorzo

Positive. Targets are selected as the spell is cast and placed on the stack (along with modes). Resolving happens later.

Elaborate breakdown:

As the assault is cast, its targets are declared. It targets the heroic creature.

Heroic is triggered, and the heroic ability is added to the stack on top of the assault.

Heroic trigger resolves. You get a token! Yay!

Assault resolves. Its target(s) are still the heroic creature, and JUST the heroic creature.

Hope that helps

Mattao19

Quote from: Gorzo on September 19, 2013, 04:01:38 AM
Positive. Targets are selected as the spell it cast and placed on the stack (along with modes). Resolving happens later.

Still confused sorry (it is 4am lol) so here's how I see it and correct me.

1. Cast  {Dauntless Onslaught}
2. Target  {Akroan Crusader}. Since the Crusader is targeted from a spell that's been cast I put a token onto the battlefield
3. Ohhhhh Id have to target both at the same time my bad

DylanW18

Quote from: Gorzo on September 19, 2013, 04:01:38 AM
Positive. Targets are selected as the spell is cast and placed on the stack (along with modes). Resolving happens later.

Elaborate breakdown:

As the assault is cast, its targets are declared. It targets the heroic creature.

Heroic is triggered, and the heroic ability is added to the stack on top of the assault.

Heroic trigger resolves. You get a token! Yay!

Assault resolves. Its target(s) are still the heroic creature, and JUST the heroic creature.

Hope that helps
Thanks Gorzo, I'm a bit tired lol

Mattao19

Quote from: Gorzo on September 19, 2013, 04:01:38 AM
Positive. Targets are selected as the spell is cast and placed on the stack (along with modes). Resolving happens later.

Elaborate breakdown:

As the assault is cast, its targets are declared. It targets the heroic creature.

Heroic is triggered, and the heroic ability is added to the stack on top of the assault.

Heroic trigger resolves. You get a token! Yay!

Assault resolves. Its target(s) are still the heroic creature, and JUST the heroic creature.

Hope that helps

It does thanks!!

Birdbrain

Quote from: Mattao19 on September 19, 2013, 03:59:00 AM
Quote from: DylanW18 on September 19, 2013, 03:33:54 AM
No, the spell resolves before the token is placed.

Are you sure doesn't it target before it resolves? Then once it's targeted that's when Heroic resolves and places a token. Then the spell resolves.
i think you want {common bond}