Imink

[Xaol]

User accused: Lmink

Reason: in the "Birdbrain's Art Contest" he made new accounts just to add votes so he could win the contest. This violates the "Do Not Lie" tenet of iMtG law.

Evidence:

Voting log for the poll in question. Every single but one vote for Imink's is by 0 posts user.

id_member   real_name   label
12068   Imink   Imink's
12691   Cuzzig   Imink's
12694   CallmeCRASH   Imink's
12705   Turtel   Imink's
12714   Dealhome   Imink's
12754   Imtheelephant   Imink's
12798   (.Y.)   Imink's
12857   Fluxcap1   Imink's
12883   jAzz   Imink's

Victims:
Myself. Infinitive Divinity (who should have first place) and anyone else who participated in the art contest.

Thoughts? As a victim and with this substantial evidence by Piotr, I feel that he is certainly guilty.

[Vampyvyrus]

Wow...just...wow.

[LadyGrixis]

And he wasn't exactly sneaky about it with the name choices, lol. That's awful!

[Xaol]

And he wasn't exactly sneaky about it with the name choices, lol. That's awful!

For sure! He has a chance to defend himself of course.

[Mlerner12]

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

[Xaol]

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

If it is decided that Lmink is guilty, yes. He will get first, I second, and birdbrain will have to do a rerun for third.

[Birdbrain]

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

the contest? Yes, infinitedivinity won. And I think I'll throw in extra prizes as well for the winners. I think we also need a way to make contests safer. So what are we going to do about this?

[Xaol]

So, does it go to InfinitiveSivinity?

the contest? Yes, infinitedivinity won. And I think I'll throw in extra prizes as well for the winners. I think we also need a way to make contests safer. So what are we going to do about this?

Well, Piotr has proven that he can monitor who votes for who. I don't see another way to cheat in this kind of thing outside out what we've just probably caught Lmink doing.

From a mod perspective, I know I will be monitoring these contests done by this kind of voting much more closely.

[Mlerner12]

Time for a dislike.

[Agrus Kos, Enforcer of Truth]

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

[#noided]

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

Hold on, I gotta load up on popcorn and soda.

[Mlerner12]

I actually disliked because of a differing reason.

[Mikefrompluto]

Don't neg karma anyone until it is resolved, "innocent until proven guilty", let's hear the defense...

Precisely. Let's ease up on the assumptions and give the man a chance to defend himself. You all would like the same thing if accused, so let's afford him the opportunity.

[Agrus Kos, Enforcer of Truth]

I actually disliked because of a differing reason.

I not judging you Mlerner, I just know people like Slenderbro hit somewhere around -30 karma during a trial.

[Mlerner12]

Wow...