Judge

Started by Zman47, July 17, 2013, 03:17:19 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Silent1236

Quote from: Kaleo42 on July 18, 2013, 02:35:15 AM
Nope a fuzed {far//away} has a mana cost of {3}{U}{B}. While fuzed it is both a blue and a black spell meaning you can not target one of the knights because it is pro black.

I'm glad you asked that question, because I had no idea that's how it worked lol. Thanks!

Gorzo

Here's a fun one for ya. I was talking with a judge on Saturday, and he quizzed me with this one.

Player A controls a {Misty Rainforest}. Player B controls {Worms of the Earth}.
What happens if player A sacrifices Misty Rainforest in order to search for {Dryad Arbor}?

Vampyvyrus

Quote from: Gorzo on July 18, 2013, 06:36:57 PM
Here's a fun one for ya. I was talking with a judge on Saturday, and he quizzed me with this one.

Player A controls a {Misty Rainforest}. Player B controls {Worms of the Earth}.
What happens if player A sacrifices Misty Rainforest in order to search for {Dryad Arbor}?
Wouldn't dryad go the the graveyard due to worms effect? Sorry I probably shouldn't be responding to these but I love tricky little questions lol. If someone could send me some in PMs I'd be pretty happy.

Kaleo42

That is correct. It actually says in the rules if a permanent would resolve that cant enter te battlefield for some reason then it is placed in the yard instead.

Coffee Vampire

That is just for permanent spells. If you activate an ability that puts a land into play, that part of the ability fails, but you still shuffle.

Kaleo42

The land is still placed in the yard. Same rule as for spells.

Edit: or not. I misread the comp rule section. The rulings on harvest cleared things up.

Coffee Vampire

Would you mind quoting the rule for it? I am on an iphone and can't really...I just saw the second ruling for worms, which says that if a spell or an ability causes you to put a land into play, the effect fails. You still do everything else though, like shuffle your library. I think that's almost the exact quote...wish this app could allow for copy paste rules!

Edit: oh saw your edit...I post too slow lol

Vampyvyrus

A good question gorzo. It confused me bc I didn't think it would go to the graveyard but also didn't think it would be exiled...and there's no limbo in magic so I took my most reasonable guess and went with it. I don't generally read card rulings unless I'm in a tournament, it's more fun to guess it and then check to see if I'm right.

Gorzo

Worms of the Earth is a pain of a card :P

Kaleo42


Mlerner12

Quote from: Gorzo on July 18, 2013, 06:36:57 PM
Here's a fun one for ya. I was talking with a judge on Saturday, and he quizzed me with this one.

Player A controls a {Misty Rainforest}. Player B controls {Worms of the Earth}.
What happens if player A sacrifices Misty Rainforest in order to search for {Dryad Arbor}?

My understanding is that it won't happen because it's a land in it's type, so it wouldn't be able to enter, and would stay in the library. and just look at Wurm's first ruling.

Mikefrompluto

Hey, is there an echo in here?

Mlerner12